“…However, various other experiments, where no clear activity change was observed upon (bulk) pH variations, demonstrated the possibility that the RDS involves no proton transfer 12 , 18 – 21 . Meanwhile, Chan group suggested a mechanism for the cation effect, called a field effect 16 , 17 , 22 , 23 : the electric double layer (EDL) field formed across the Helmholtz layer would stabilize the intermediates ( e.g ., *CO 2 ) via adsorbate dipole-field interaction, which can be modulated by the degree of M + accumulation at the interface 17 , 24 . Also, using the scanning electrochemical microscopic technique, the Koper group demonstrated an absence of CO 2 RR activity for CO formation without M + , which led them to propose a mechanism based on a M + -complexation (or coupling) to the CO 2 − intermediate in conjunction with their ab initio molecular dynamics (AIMD) simulation results 13 .…”