The interconversion between fumarate and succinate is
fundamental
to the energy metabolism of nearly all organisms. This redox reaction
is catalyzed by a large family of enzymes, fumarate reductases and
succinate dehydrogenases, using hydride and proton transfers from
a flavin cofactor and a conserved Arg side-chain. These flavoenzymes
also have substantial biomedical and biotechnological importance.
Therefore, a detailed understanding of their catalytic mechanisms
is valuable. Here, calibrated electronic structure calculations in
a cluster model of the active site of the Fcc3 fumarate
reductase were employed to investigate various reaction pathways and
possible intermediates in the enzymatic environment and to dissect
interactions that contribute to catalysis of fumarate reduction. Carbanion,
covalent adduct, carbocation, and radical intermediates were examined.
Significantly lower barriers were obtained for mechanisms via carbanion
intermediates, with similar activation energies for hydride and proton
transfers. Interestingly, the carbanion bound to the active site is
best described as an enolate. Hydride transfer is stabilized by a
preorganized charge dipole in the active site and by the restriction
of the C1–C2 bond in a twisted conformation of the otherwise
planar fumarate dianion. But, protonation of a fumarate carboxylate
and quantum tunneling effects are not critical for catalysis of the
hydride transfer. Calculations also suggest that the driving force
for enzyme turnover is provided by regeneration of the catalytic Arg,
either coupled with flavin reduction and decomposition of a proposed
transient state or directly from the solvent. The detailed mechanistic
description of enzymatic reduction of fumarate provided here clarifies
previous contradictory views and provides new insights into catalysis
by essential flavoenzyme reductases and dehydrogenases.