Modernity Against Modernity: Wang Hui's Critical History of Chinese Thought

Abstract

In the last fifteen years or so, Chinese intellectuals have been heatedly debating the complex relationships between China's prospects, China's past, and the modern predicament. In this context Wang Hui has emerged as one of China's most challenging and controversial intellectuals. His work is controversial. At a time when intellectuals take modernization as a goal, Wang has consistently voiced reservations. Readers find his works challenging because, instead of criticizing modernity or capitalism from simple moral tenets, Wang has always sought to redefine the terms of the debate through detailed and sensitive historical analysis. Hence amidst his busy life as editor, professor, and polemicist, Wang has devoted more than ten years to writing his magisterial four volume book The Rise of Modern Chinese Thought (Zhongguo sixiang de xingqi), in which he fundamentally rethinks the relationship between modernity and Chinese thought. However, Wang's book is not just an immense contribution to historical and historiographical scholarship; his work is a self-consciously political intervention. Specifically, he highlights the role of intellectual history as critique and attempts to recover repressed elements of the past in order to question the structures that govern the present. In the last line of the conclusion to his book he writes, “the history that modernity loftily and even proudly rejects contains the inspiration and possibilities for overcoming its crisis.” Taking China as his focus, Wang attempts to write this history.

Reawakening a Revolutionary Party: The Ancient and Modern Princes in Wang Hui’s Political Theory

“…One may even argue that "antimodern modernity" is the core theme of Wang's entire intellectual project, including his recent writings on Chinese history. See Murthy (2006).…”

Contextual influences on marketing and consumerism: an East Asian perspective

“…One ideology long shared by all three ancient societies is feudalism, which dominated their political structures and shaped their economic systems (Cartwright, 2019; Ellington and Ferrarini, 2017; Murthy, 2006). Ancient East Asian states created hierarchical political systems comprised of lords and vassals (Cartwright, 2019; Feng, 2003).…”