Modelling the dynamics of complex early design processes: an agent-based approach

Abstract

Among the different phases of complex design processes, early design is the most dynamic and unpredictable stage since it involves a great deal of uncertainty, concurrency of activity streams, collaborative design iterations, and distributed and adaptive decision-making behaviour in response to both organizational commitments and to the occurrence of unforeseen events. This paper argues that current activity-based modelling approaches have limited ability to capture the dynamics of complex early design processes and explores novel modelling approaches. The development of an Agent Model for Planning and rEsearch of eaRly dEsign (AMPERE) aiming to capture various facets of uncertainty, iteration, collaboration and adaptation is described. The model was developed to tackle early design phases of complex systems, with the ability to deal with changes in requirements coming in and affecting the subsequent design evolution while design tasks are on-going. Initial results from agent-based simulations are presented, showing how the agent-based approach can support industrial organizations evaluating likely early design project performance and understanding complex cause-effect relationships that may affect project outcomes. Early design planning support from the agent model is demonstrated through an investigation to the likely project performance for varying levels of externally driven requirements change.

Simulation of Feedback Loops in Engineering Design

“…Mykoniatis and Angelopoulou (2020) provide a framework for integrating different simulation methods in different domains such as socio-technical systems, cyber-physical systems, business and healthcare organizations. Agent-based simulations of new product development processes seek to integrate in a much more sophisticated way the social interaction between agents, including skill levels and behaviours (see Hassannezhad et al, 2019;Fernandes et al, 2017;Crowder et al, 2012). Other simulation methods are now integrating hybrid simulation and multi-paradigm simulation to capture the complexity of real systems, providing a more comprehensive and holistic view of the system under investigation.…”

A Framework for Technology Driven Design: Criticality and Comfort Zone for Emerging Technologies

“…The reason is related to the cost, as well as the uncertainty, of developing a new system, which is around threequarters of a program's total life cycle (Fernandes et al, 2015;Georgiadis et al, 2013). Actually, most of the cost of a system is determined during the design phase because of multiple iterations, intrinsic (Fernandes et al, 2017;McNerney et al, 2011). At the base of the design decision-making process, there are the sets of systems requirements that should be managed and developed.…”

Idea selection in design teams: a computational framework and insights in the presence of influencers

“…Despite its limitations, the ABM approach has been used in a variety of different fields, including energy management (Zhao, Suryanarayanan & Simões 2013), stock trading (Luo, Liu & Davis 2002) and spatial planning (Ligtenberg et al 2004) as is it an efficient way to represent complex phenomena. However, in the field of studying design teams, agent-based models have been used to model collaborative behaviour as they are efficient in modelling dynamic systems, interactions and features like learning and adaptation (Fernandes et al 2017; Lapp, Jablokow & McComb 2019; Cao et al 2020).…”