Modelling community-control strategies to protect hospital resources during an influenza pandemic in Ottawa, Canada

Abstract

BackgroundA novel influenza virus has emerged to produce a global pandemic four times in the past one hundred years, resulting in millions of infections, hospitalizations and deaths. There is substantial uncertainty about when, where and how the next influenza pandemic will occur.MethodsWe developed a novel mathematical model to chart the evolution of an influenza pandemic. We estimate the likely burden of future influenza pandemics through health and economic endpoints. An important component of this is the adequacy of existing hospital-resource capacity. Using a simulated population reflective of Ottawa, Canada, we model the potential impact of a future influenza pandemic under different combinations of pharmaceutical and non-pharmaceutical interventions.ResultsThere was substantial variation in projected pandemic impact and outcomes across intervention scenarios. In a population of 1.2 million, the illness attack rate ranged from 8.4% (all interventions) to 54.5% (no interventions); peak acute care hospital capacity ranged from 0.2% (all interventions) to 13.8% (no interventions); peak ICU capacity ranged from 1.1% (all interventions) to 90.2% (no interventions); and mortality ranged from 11 (all interventions) to 363 deaths (no interventions). Associated estimates of economic burden ranged from CAD $115 million to over $2 billion when extended mass school closure was implemented.DiscussionChildren accounted for a disproportionate number of pandemic infections, particularly in household settings. Pharmaceutical interventions effectively reduced peak and total pandemic burden without affecting timing, while non-pharmaceutical measures delayed and attenuated pandemic wave progression. The timely implementation of a layered intervention bundle appeared likely to protect hospital resource adequacy in Ottawa. The adaptable nature of this model provides value in informing pandemic preparedness policy planning in situations of uncertainty, as scenarios can be updated in real time as more data become available. However—given the inherent uncertainties of model assumptions—results should be interpreted with caution.

Cost-effectiveness of emergency preparedness measures in response to infectious respiratory disease outbreaks: a systematic review and econometric analysis

“…Similarly, in a study that included 762 H1N1 cases from both Australia and New Zealand, the mean cost per ICU patient was 61 368 € 2017 , with a per-day cost of 4767 € 2017 . 20 On the contrary, the non-ICU patient had a mean cost of 10 755 € 2017 ; however, overall Cost-effectiveness studies of measures in averting and/or responding to infectious respiratory disease outbreaks We identified 11 studies [23][24][25][26][27][28][29][30][31][32][33] referring to preparedness, preventative and response measures, to influenza outbreaks, presented in detail in online supplemental appendix 6. Two studies were observational (based in the Netherlands and the UK), 23 24 and the remaining nine were simulation models (four US models, with one study each modelled for Canada, France, Australia, Israel and one referring to developed countries in general).…”

Resource Allocation and Pandemic Response: An Evidence Synthesis To Inform Decision Making

“…196 An influenza simulation tested seven interventions (e.g., social distancing); the authors concluded that with implementing all seven, the illness attack rate would be around 8 percent and with no intervention it would be 54 percent. 163 The COVID-19 studies are described in the subgroup analysis, and all other included studies are shown in Appendix C.…”

COVID-19 Control Strategies and Intervention Effects in Resource Limited Settings: A Modeling Study

“…Individuals placed in home quarantine have the same reductions but with only 50% compliance. 31,32 These estimates are summarized in Table 2. Since a lockdown is already in place, we did not analyze the individual effect of school and workplace closures.…”