Modeling the Longitudinal Direct and Indirect Effects of Attitudes, Self‐Efficacy, and Behavioral Intentions on Practice Behavior Outcomes of Suicide Intervention Training
Abstract:The purpose of this study was to use a longitudinal path analysis to test attitudes toward suicide prevention, self-efficacy, and behavioral intentions as mediators/moderators of clinical skill development over time following suicide intervention training. Results support a direct effect of attitudes on practice behaviors and self-efficacy, but no moderating effect. Self-efficacy performed as a mediator of practice behaviors over time. Behavioral intention had a direct effect on practice behaviors and mediated… Show more
“…As hypothesized, behavioral health providers who reported being more confidence in their skills related to suicide care were also more likely to incorporate best practices. This result is in accordance with previous research that suggests that level of comfort and self‐efficacy beliefs associated with working with suicidal people are related to greater use of evidenced‐based practices, even when controlling for individual differences and case load (Lee, Osteen, & Frey, ; Osteen, Frey, Woods, Ko, & Shipe, ; Roush et al., ). In fact, one previous study found that providers with higher comfort levels, regardless of fear of negative outcomes, were more likely to adequately implement suicide risk assessments (Roush et al., ).…”
Section: Discussionsupporting
confidence: 92%
“…At last, it will be important to develop studies exploring whether some modalities of training (e.g., experiential training versus online training) are associated with higher confidence and implementation of practices among behavioral health providers (Roush et al., ; Silva et al., ). For instance, previous research has suggested that although most trainings might produce changes in knowledge and attitudes, it is through active learning strategies that behavioral changes are produced (Beidas & Kendall, ; Osteen et al., ). In sum, our results underscore the importance of examining packages of trainings for suicide prevention and of establishing if there is incremental utility of delivering multiple trainings to increase levels of confidence and practice among clinicians.…”
Objective
This study examined whether (1) behavioral health providers were more likely to implement best practices when they were more confident in their abilities, (2) number of suicide prevention trainings was positively associated with perceived confidence in abilities and implementation of evidence‐based practices, and (3) specific trainings were more impactful than others on increasing providers’ level of confidence and/or practices.
Method
Providers (N = 137) at three rural community behavioral health centers who had opportunities to attend multiple suicide prevention trainings completed the Zero Suicide Workforce Survey, a measure to evaluate staff knowledge, practices, and confidence in caring for patients at risk of suicide.
Results
There was a moderate association between provider's practice and confidence. The number of attended trainings had a significant correlation with both practice and confidence. Particular trainings demonstrated differential effects on provider's practice and confidence.
Conclusion
These results suggest that behavioral health providers who are confident in their skills in assessing and treating suicide risk are more likely incorporate best practices into their clinical work. Also, it appears there is a small but significant benefit to multiple trainings for increasing both practice and confidence among providers.
“…As hypothesized, behavioral health providers who reported being more confidence in their skills related to suicide care were also more likely to incorporate best practices. This result is in accordance with previous research that suggests that level of comfort and self‐efficacy beliefs associated with working with suicidal people are related to greater use of evidenced‐based practices, even when controlling for individual differences and case load (Lee, Osteen, & Frey, ; Osteen, Frey, Woods, Ko, & Shipe, ; Roush et al., ). In fact, one previous study found that providers with higher comfort levels, regardless of fear of negative outcomes, were more likely to adequately implement suicide risk assessments (Roush et al., ).…”
Section: Discussionsupporting
confidence: 92%
“…At last, it will be important to develop studies exploring whether some modalities of training (e.g., experiential training versus online training) are associated with higher confidence and implementation of practices among behavioral health providers (Roush et al., ; Silva et al., ). For instance, previous research has suggested that although most trainings might produce changes in knowledge and attitudes, it is through active learning strategies that behavioral changes are produced (Beidas & Kendall, ; Osteen et al., ). In sum, our results underscore the importance of examining packages of trainings for suicide prevention and of establishing if there is incremental utility of delivering multiple trainings to increase levels of confidence and practice among clinicians.…”
Objective
This study examined whether (1) behavioral health providers were more likely to implement best practices when they were more confident in their abilities, (2) number of suicide prevention trainings was positively associated with perceived confidence in abilities and implementation of evidence‐based practices, and (3) specific trainings were more impactful than others on increasing providers’ level of confidence and/or practices.
Method
Providers (N = 137) at three rural community behavioral health centers who had opportunities to attend multiple suicide prevention trainings completed the Zero Suicide Workforce Survey, a measure to evaluate staff knowledge, practices, and confidence in caring for patients at risk of suicide.
Results
There was a moderate association between provider's practice and confidence. The number of attended trainings had a significant correlation with both practice and confidence. Particular trainings demonstrated differential effects on provider's practice and confidence.
Conclusion
These results suggest that behavioral health providers who are confident in their skills in assessing and treating suicide risk are more likely incorporate best practices into their clinical work. Also, it appears there is a small but significant benefit to multiple trainings for increasing both practice and confidence among providers.
“…Practice skills were not tested directly, but improvement in self-efficacy is still important, since a sense of confidence is critical for motivation and performance (Bandura 2001;Bandura & Locke, 2003). Self-efficacy, "the belief in one's capabilities to organize and execute specific courses of action" (Ozer et al, 2004, p. 102), has been studied as a key factor linked to subsequent behavior and application of practice skills (Kunst, Mitchell, & Johnson, 2017;Lippke, Wiedemann, Ziegelmann, Reuter, & Schwarzer, 2009;Osteen, Frey, Woods, Ko, & Shipe, 2016) The online training successfully improved service providers' knowledge relevant to effective practice with youth and young adults with mental health needs. Although knowledge scores improved significantly for both sets of service providers, group membership was shown to be relevant.…”
Service providers working with transition-aged young people with mental health disorders require specialized research-based training to better meet their needs. A 10-module interactive online training program, Promoting Positive Pathways to Adulthood (PPPA), was developed to build service provider competencies to improve outcomes for the youth with whom they work. In total, 19 organizations participated in a longitudinal quasi-experimental study that compared training outcomes for participants receiving PPPA online training only (Group 1) with those receiving PPPA online training with team-based practice activities (Group 2). Most of the 63 service providers participating in the training were females, below 40 years, had at least one college degree, and were non-Hispanic White. Both groups made significant gains in their transition-related knowledge, and their self-efficacy to provide transition services. Group 2 with additional practice activities achieved significantly higher knowledge scores than Group 1 receiving online-only training. Team-based activities evaluated by Group 2 participants as more engaging and culturally relevant were also rated as more likely to help improve practice. Future research is needed to track youth outcomes after service provider training, and to examine the organizational supports necessary to promote knowledge translation for transition service providers.
“…For example, researchers may report the impact of training on practice behaviors, attitudes, self-efficacy, and knowledge for each individual construct without regard to the interaction of these multiple factors. Research is available that explores the potential moderating roles of baseline characteristics such as professional role and experience on the intervention behaviors with evidence supporting the notion that the development of intervention behaviors is impacted by more than just the training in and of itself (Osteen, Frey, Woods, Ko, & Shipe, 2016;Tompkins, Witt, & Abraibesh, 2010). This approach has allowed the field to make statements about whether or not training is effective in improving these outcomes, but it has done little to explore the ''how/why'' question or to develop strong causal models linking these components.…”
Section: Core Training Constructsmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Lee, Osteen, and Frey (2016) applied the SCT framework to a hierarchical analysis of change in clinical behaviors and found mixed support for the model; the results supported the role of self-efficacy in behavioral change but not for attitudes after controlling for individual and work-related characteristics. Osteen, Frey, Woods, Ko, and Shipe (2016) also used an SCT approach to analyze the direct and indirect effects of knowledge, attitudes, efficacy, and motivation of posttraining intervention behaviors and found strong evidence for the indirect effects of attitudes on self-efficacy and motivation and the indirect relationship of self-efficacy to posttraining intervention behaviors.…”
Objective: Suicide is a significant public and mental health crisis in the United States. Training providers in suicide assessment and response is designated as one of the primary strategies for reducing deaths by suicide. Research has established that suicide intervention training is effective, but little work has been published on potential mediators of skill development and use. Method: Secondary data analysis of a randomized trial of the Question, Persuade, and Refer gatekeeper training with master of social work students. Path analysis was used to estimate mediated effects of knowledge, attitudes, reluctance, and self-efficacy on behavior outcomes. Results: Results suggest improvements in posttraining measures for knowledge, attitudes, self-efficacy, reluctance, and the use of gatekeeper behaviors, but there was no supporting evidence for the presence of mediated effects on behavior. Only self-efficacy demonstrated a strong direct relationship with gatekeeper behaviors. Conclusions: Ongoing evaluation is needed with an added interest in self-efficacy and how it can be enhanced through training.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.