Modeling the Impact of Integrating HIV and Outpatient Health Services on Patient Waiting Times in an Urban Health Clinic in Zambia

Abstract

BackgroundRapid scale up of HIV treatment programs in sub-Saharan Africa has refueled the long-standing health policy debate regarding the merits and drawbacks of vertical and integrated system. Recent pilots of integrating outpatient and HIV services have shown an improvement in some patient outcomes but deterioration in waiting times, which can lead to worse health outcomes in the long run.MethodsA pilot intervention involving integration of outpatient and HIV services in an urban primary care facility in Lusaka, Zambia was studied. Data on waiting time of patients during two seven-day periods before and six months after the integration were collected using a time and motion study. Statistical tests were conducted to investigate whether the two observation periods differed in operational details such as staffing, patient arrival rates, mix of patients etc. A discrete event simulation model was constructed to facilitate a fair comparison of waiting times before and after integration. The simulation model was also used to develop alternative configurations of integration and to estimate the resulting waiting times.ResultsComparison of raw data showed that waiting times increased by 32% and 36% after integration for OPD and ART patients respectively (p<0.01). Using simulation modeling, we found that a large portion of this increase could be explained by changes in operational conditions before and after integration such as reduced staff availability (p<0.01) and longer breaks between consecutive patients (p<0.05). Controlling for these differences, integration of services, per se, would have resulted in a significant decrease in waiting times for OPD and a moderate decrease for HIV services.ConclusionsIntegrating health services has the potential of reducing waiting times due to more efficient use of resources. However, one needs to ensure that other operational factors such as staff availability are not adversely affected due to integration.

Integrating family planning into HIV care in western Kenya: HIV care providers’ perspectives and experiences one year following integration

“…Given that providers were interviewed one year after FP/HIV integration began, the challenges associated with implementing new protocols may have been more acutely felt. Further research is needed to evaluate how to address obstacles like human resource shortages in order to capitalize on the service delivery efficiencies that can be produced by integration efforts (Topp et al, 2013; Deo et al, 2012) and that could be especially beneficial in resource-constrained settings.…”

HIV, Tuberculosis, and Noncommunicable Diseases

“…Wait times increased from 91 to 127 minutes in a Zambian clinic due to staff and patient flow problems after integration of HIV services with primary healthcare. 161 Longer wait times could increase loss to follow-up or exacerbate stigma, 162-164 and TB transmissions could even be increased. 69,165 Staff training and program quality might be less effective or more costly when multiple interventions are provided together.…”

Prevention of mother-to-child HIV transmission within the continuum of maternal, newborn, and child health services

“…However, adoption of such models may come at a cost. In the Zambia study, waiting times increased for all patients at newly integrated sites, delays largely attributed to inadequate staffing levels and longer breaks between consecutive patient visits (20). Investigators in Mozambique found higher rates of attrition among patients attending integrated clinics for more than 6 months (hazard ratio [HR]: 1.75, 1.04–2.94) (21).…”