Modeling antibiotic resistance in the microbiota using multi-level Petri Nets

Abstract

BackgroundThe unregulated use of antibiotics not only in clinical practice but also in farm animals breeding is causing a unprecedented growth of antibiotic resistant bacterial strains. This problem can be analyzed at different levels, from the antibiotic resistance spreading dynamics at the host population level down to the molecular mechanisms at the bacteria level. In fact, antibiotic administration policies and practices affect the societal system where individuals developing resistance interact with each other and with the environment. Each individual can be seen as a meta-organism together with its associated microbiota, which proves to have a prominent role in the resistance spreading dynamics. Eventually, in each microbiota, bacterial population dynamics and vertical or horizontal gene transfer events activate cellular and molecular mechanisms for resistance spreading that can also be possible targets for its prevention.ResultsIn this work we show how to use the Nets-Within-Nets formalism to model the dynamics between different antibiotic administration protocols and antibiotic resistance, both at the individuals population and at the single microbiota level. Three application examples are presented to show the flexibility of this approach in integrating heterogeneous information in the same model, a fundamental property when creating computational models complex biological systems. Simulations allow to explicitly take into account timing and stochastic events.ConclusionsThis work demonstrates how the NWN formalism can be used to efficiently model antibiotic resistance population dynamics at different levels of detail. The proposed modeling approach not only provides a valuable tool for investigating causal, quantitative relations between different events and mechanisms, but can be also used as a valid support for decision making processes and protocol development.

Bacterial Protein Interaction Networks: Connectivity is Ruled by Gene Conservation, Essentiality and Function

“…In particular, we believe that a recent approach based on the introduction of the multiple-layer networks could be of great potential interest ( e.g. to search for a general scheme behind antimicrobial resistance [ 46 - 50 ]).…”

From Pathophysiological Hypotheses to Case–Control Study Design: Resistance from Antibiotic Exposure in Community-Onset Infections

“…It is notable that, while case–control studies evaluate risk factors involved in the transition from a step to another of the pathophysiological hypothesis, they do not discriminate the exact intra-host and host-microbiota mechanisms and dynamics involving the antibiotic in this transition, which are better approached through mathematical models and require microbiome analysis [ 10 , 81 , 82 ]. In the example discussed above, a micro-level pathophysiological hypothesis could involve further steps between asymptomatic carriage and infection with ESBL-p E. coli ST131 ( Figure 1 ): (1) depletion in other phylotypes of E. coli in the host microbiota [ 64 ]; (2) increase in lateral gene transfer of the ESBL gene within or between bacterial species [ 81 ]; (3) increase in density of ESBL-p E. coli ST131 among the host’s flora [ 64 ] (which could be important for infections such as BSI [ 63 ]), with a loss of bacterial diversity. All these steps could be happening within the host microbiota of subjects carrying ESBL-p E. coli ST131 and be influenced by the selective pressure of antibiotics.…”

Computational Methods for Biofabrication in Tissue Engineering and Regenerative Medicine - a literature review

“…A model that aims to express biological complexity must consider that physical parts used in biofabrication are multi-level systems, from the single bioprocess to the multicellular aggregate [34]. To capture their complexity, models must express multi-level and quantitative information, as well as the dynamic simulation of complex biological processes [35, 36]. Multi-level and hybrid modeling approaches consistently combine models based on different formalisms and centered over different system levels to comprise more of their hierarchical organization, and heterogeneity [37].…”