The following selectivities are reported for partitioning of the R-(N,N-dimethylthiocarbamoyl)-4methoxybenzyl carbocation 1 + between nucleophilic addition of π-nucleophiles and a solvent of 50:50 (v:v) acetonitrile/water at 25°C (nucleophile, k Nu /k s ): pyrrole, 23 M -1 ; 2-methoxythiophene, ≈2 M -1 . No nucleophile adducts (<2% of total products) were detected from the reaction of this carbocation in the same solvent containing the following carbon nucleophiles: thiophene (0.10 M), furan (0.10 M), ethyl 1-propenyl ether (0.10 M), amd 1-cyclohexenyl trimethylsilyl ether (0.01 M). These results show that only π-nucleophiles with Mayr nucleophilicity parameters greater than N ≈ 6 are sufficiently reactive to compete with nucleophilic aqueous solvents for addition to 1 + , and they provide support for a simple relationship between the Ritchie N + scale of nucleophilicity in water and the Mayr N scale of nucleophilicity in weakly polar nonnucleophilic solvents. 2,3 Our data require a large effective molarity for the intramolecular addition of a trisubstituted alkene to an allylic carbocation.In recent years there have been many determinations of rate constants for the addition of nucleophiles to carbocations in a variety of solvents, including weakly polar, aprotic, nonnucleophilic solvents such as dichloromethane; 2,3 polar, aprotic, and weakly nucleophilic solvents such as acetonitrile; 4 polar, protic, and weakly nucleophilic solvents such as 1,1,1,3,3,3-hexafluoro-2-propanol; 5,6 and polar, protic, and strongly nucleophilic solvents such as water. 7,8 An important conclusion from this work is that there are large decreases in the reactivity of anionic nucleophiles 4,9 and neutral amines 10 with increasing stabilization of the nucleophilic reagent by hydrogen bonding to solvent. This results from the requirement for the loss of these stabilizing hydrogen-bonding interactions on proceeding to the transition state for the nucleophile addition reaction.The effect of polar protic solvents on the nucleophilic reactivity of alkenes and other π-nucleophiles has not been investigated in detail, but the lack of data in aqueous solvents might suggest that π-nucleophiles are simply too weakly nucleophilic to compete with nucleophilic solvents for addition to unstable carbocations. However, recent studies of photolytically generated ring-substituted diarylmethyl carbocations in acetonitrile have shown that the second-order rate constants for the addition of activated alkenes, such as vinyl ethers and silyl enol ethers, are significantly larger than that for addition of water. 11 These results suggest that it should be possible to study the addition of strongly activated nucleophilic alkenes to carbocations in an aqueous solvent, but we are not aware of any reports of such studies in the chemical literature.We recently reported that the π-nucleophile 2 is 70 000-fold more reactive than a solvent of 50:50 (v:v) methanol/water toward the R-(N,N-dimethylthiocarbamoyl)-4-methoxybenzyl carbocation 1 + (k alk , Scheme 1), 12 g...