Model-independent limits and constraints on extended theories of gravity from cosmic reconstruction techniques

Abstract

Abstract. The onset of dark energy domination depends on the particular gravitational theory driving the cosmic evolution. Model independent techniques are crucial to test the both the present ΛCDM cosmological paradigm and alternative theories, making the least possible number of assumptions about the Universe. In this paper we investigate whether cosmography is able to distinguish between different gravitational theories, by determining bounds on model parameters for three different extensions of General Relativity, namely quintessence, F (T ) and f (R) gravitational theories. We expand each class of theories in powers of redshift z around the present time, making no additional assumptions. This procedure is an extension of previous work and can be seen as the most general approach for testing extended theories of gravity through the use of cosmography. In the case of F (T ) and f (R) theories, we show that some assumptions on model parameters often made in previous works are superfluous or even unjustified.We use data from the Union 2.1 supernovae catalogue, baryonic acoustic oscillation data and H(z) differential age compilations, which probe cosmology on different scales of the cosmological evolution. We perform a Monte Carlo analysis using a Metropolis-Hastings algorithm with a Gelman-Rubin convergence criterion, reporting 1-σ and 2-σ confidence levels. To do so, we perform two distinct fits, assuming only data within z < 1 first and then without limitations in redshift. We obtain the corresponding numerical intervals in which coefficients span, and find that the data is compatible the ΛCDM limit of all three theories at the 1-σ level, while still compatible with quite a large portion of parameter space. We compare our results to the truncated ΛCDM paradigm, demonstrating that our bounds divert from the expectations of previous works, showing that the permitted regions of coefficients are significantly modified and in general widened with respect to values usually reported in the existing literature. Finally, we test the extended theories through the Bayesian selection criteria AIC and BIC.ArXiv ePrint: 1608.03746

The realistic models of relativistic stars in f ( R ) = R + αR 2 gravity

“…Other approaches recently explored have considered model-independent (cosmographic) techniques in order to reconstruct the underlying theory capable of causing the observed cosmological evolution once the Copernican principle is assumed (c.f. [9,10] …”

Lemaître Class Dark Energy Model for Relaxing Cosmological Constant

“…Various models have been developed with a dark energy of non-vacuum origin which mimics cosmological constant when necessary (for a review [5,6]), and confronted with cosmography tests [7,8]. Model-independent evidence for dark energy evolution from BAO data prefers theories in which cosmological constant Λ relaxes from a large initial value [9].…”

Towards New Constraints in Extended Theories of Gravity: Cosmography and Gravitational-Wave Signals from Neutron Stars

“…Nonetheless, there were indeed seminal references for cosmographic techniques in the context of f (R) theories included [40,41,43,44], whereas for F(T ) they were restricted to [45]. In our recent investigations [46] we expanded each class of extended theory under consideration in powers of redshift z around the present time, making no additional assumptions on the values of the theory's parameters at the present epoch.…”