Modding as Rating Behavior in Virtual Communities: The Case of Rooster Teeth Productions

Abstract

Virtual communities that make use of social network site features blend known applications of virtual communities. These communities can be simultaneously social and commercial, organization sponsored and heavily relying on member interaction. We explore modding behavior that allows members to evaluate other members' contributions both with numerical value and qualitative rating. We show that approximately half of all members received mods on their comments, that the majority of mods given were positive, and that the amount of mods received for a comment was related to the position of the comment in the community website's thread. Contributing to the emerging literature of social network sites and virtual communities, we discuss implications for theory, future research and management.

Social Software and Strategy

“…Social software also enables interaction between online consumers and users, their product development efforts (F€ uller et al, 2010), their mutual rating of ideas and comments (Haefliger et al, 2009), and provides online community members with a basic infrastructure for their work (Lee and Cole, 2003;Ren et al, 2007;Kohler et al, 2011). Thus, social software becomes an exciting topic for strategy practitioners and scholars.…”

Monuments of cyberspace: Designing the Internet beyond the network framework

“…A third category of communities focusses on a specific commercial good, which structures around it its own community of users. This wide category of client communities, varying from fashion consumers (Maria and Finotto, 2008) to video gamers (Haefliger, et al, 2009) highlights how a product becomes the intermediary between enterprises and users, enabling a feedback acquisition or user-self-regulation. In this situation, friendship emerges through the activity of consumption, e.g., in the well-known case of Harley-Davidson motorcyclists.…”

Empathy in the Business Model: How Facebook and Google Maps Manage External Problem-Solving Processes

“…managed to capture scientific expertise of 26 firms by sharing scientific problems with over 80,000 independent scientists from over 150 countries. In parallel, Soukhoroukova et al (2012) suggested a community design for enterprises to capture good ideas through idea markets Haefliger et al (2009). suggested that rating mechanisms within an online community can capture evaluations of contributions by members of the community.…”