Mobile phone paradox: A two-path model connecting mobile phone use and feeling of loneliness for Filipino domestic workers in Hong Kong

Abstract

Due to separation from their families and friends in their home countries and constrained living conditions in the host countries, migrant workers usually are found to experience loneliness. Compared with male migrant workers, female migrant workers are more vulnerable and likely to experience higher levels of psychological problems. The ubiquity of mobile phones enables migrant workers to access resources and social support to help to alleviate loneliness. However, research also suggests that mobile phone use may lead to a higher level of loneliness because problematic or excessive use displaces meaningful social interactions. This study investigates this mobile phone paradox among Filipino domestic workers (FDWs) in Hong Kong. Specifically, it explores the relationships between mobile phone use and two types of loneliness, namely social and emotional loneliness. Further, informed by the augmentation hypothesis and the displacement hypothesis, this research advances a two-path model to illustrate how mobile phone use connects with loneliness through social support and problematic mobile phone use. Findings from a survey of 492 FDWs reveal disjunctive effects. There is no direct correlation between mobile phone use and the two types of loneliness. Both problematic mobile phone use and social support are found to mediate the negative association between mobile phone use and social loneliness, while only problematic mobile phone use mediates the positive association between mobile phone use and emotional loneliness. Implications of the research on migrant workers’ mobile phone use and practical implications for social work and government efforts in helping FDWs dealing with loneliness are discussed.

Technologies of inclusion and marginalization: Mobile phones and multiple exclusion homeless women

“…Media communications studies has paid some attention to mobile phones and homelessness (Galperin et al, 2021; Humphry, 2021; Marler, 2019), and to homeless communities’ use of social media platforms (Buente et al, 2020). Within the ICT for development literature and the broader field of development studies, many studies have problematized marginalized women's relationships with mobile phones (Bailur et al, 2015; Oosten, 2021; Porter, 2011; Porter et al, 2019; Ramisch, 2016; Wyche et al, 2016; Zelezny-Green, 2018), exploring the negative impacts of excessive or uncontrolled phone, social media, and internet use on face-to-face social relationships and mental health (Kim, 2017; Zhong et al, 2022). However, as it is typically premised upon a model of stable family and living arrangements, this literature stands in stark contrast to MEH people's experiences of using mobile phones, which are characterized by multiple forms of instability, including periods of disconnection, interrupted credit, phone breakages and loss, and difficulties with charging mobile phones and accessing Wi-Fi.…”

“…Although a mobile phone offers users a wide range of functions, the ability to use these is shaped by users’ knowledge and how they are situated structurally in society: their education, income, or residential status. The concept of affordances provides a theoretical armory for understanding the relationship between users and the functionality of mobile phones (Schrock, 2015; Wyche et al, 2018; Zheng & Yu, 2016). Originating in psychology (Gibson, 1977), this concept has been widely used in media and communications studies (Evans et al, 2017; Nagy & Neff, 2015) and information systems disciplines (Faraj & Azad, 2012; Pozzi et al, 2014).…”

Psychological perspectives on mobile media: A flyover review

“…One classic example of this deep psychological connection is the phenomenon of "phantom vibrations"the misplaced sensation that one's device is ringing, vibrating, or blinking (Sauer et al, 2015). Echoing the broader literature on communication technologies, several studies have exposed the paradoxical role of mobile connectedness in increasing feelings of loneliness as well as intimacy and social support (Liu et al, 2014;Mascheroni & Vincent, 2016;Stevic et al, 2021;Zhong et al, 2022). On the disconnection side, there has also been significant attention paid to researching the value of "digital detoxes" (Radtke et al, 2021).…”

Community organizations and ethnic media working with foreign household service workers: Applying communication infrastructure theory to migrant health

“…Social networks, specifically employers and peers, may serve not just as direct sources of health information but can become “access points to health institutions and services” (Piocos et al, 2021, p. 95). Beyond medical concerns, access to interpersonal network via technologically mediated communication, primarily media, also helps in addressing mental health issues and general well-being of many FHSWs in HK (Cheng & Vicera, 2022; Zhong et al, 2022).…”