Mitigating asymmetric information to enhance MSME Islamic financial inclusion by Islamic banks in Indonesia

Abstract

Purpose This study aims to explore and analyse the credit risk assessment procedure conducted by the Indonesian Islamic banks to address the issue of asymmetric information among their micro-, small- and medium-sized enterprise (MSME) clients. This study also investigates the gaps in credit risk assessment procedures by comparing Islamic banks’ practices and presenting several recommendations to reinforce the credit risk evaluation procedures and eventually promote more inclusion of the MSME segment into the Islamic financial services. Design/methodology/approach This paper adopts a qualitative method by implementing a multi-case study research strategy. The data were gathered primarily through an interview approach by incorporating purposive uncontrolled quota sampling. Findings The result of this study implies that the Islamic banks in Indonesia have their own unique approaches and strategies in assessing the credit risk and have several similarities in performing their evaluation procedures for the MSME. Despite seemingly adequate approaches and measures taken by the Islamic banks to eliminate the asymmetric information problem, the study identifies several gaps that occur within the Islamic banks’ methods of credit risk assessment. Research limitations/implications Since this study focuses on Indonesia and emphasises the two segments of Islamic banks, which consist of Islamic commercial and rural banks, in performing the MSME credit risk assessment; therefore, the findings of this study were limited around the observed Islamic banks within the MSME segment purview. Practical implications By referring to the recommendations as proposed by this paper, four implications could be expected from adopting these respective recommendations, among others: more effective evaluation procedures for the MSME, provision of a clear path and more efficient approach to assess the MSME units, lower financing cost and increase the confidence of Islamic banking industry in disbursing more financing to the MSME sector. This mechanism will potentially improve Islamic financial inclusion for the MSME due to the greater access to financial services; hence, the sector could contribute even more to Indonesia’s growing economy. Originality/value By incorporating a multi-case study among Indonesian Islamic banks pertaining to their methods in evaluating MSME customers, this study identifies several gaps affecting the effectiveness of MSME credit risk assessment. Furthermore, this study also presents a proposed framework to address these gaps accordingly by suggesting the salient strategies to minimise the issues of information asymmetry and enhance the MSME credit risk assessment procedure.

Indonesia Islamic Bank Development: An Interpretive Structural Modeling (ISM)

“…In this case, the regulation that provides support will be expected to help facilitate the development of the Islamic banks institution in the future. Several recent studies related to the development of Islamic banks in Indonesia can be seen, for example, in Saifurrahman & Kassim (2023), Azizah (2023), andJan et al, (2023).…”

Corporate Integrity and Information Asymmetry: Evidence from Iran.

“…Corporate integrity would prompt the company to perceive the fact that the actions and functions of different sections of the company are monitored and controlled in a public field by all stakeholders and restructure the company and implement a more transparent level of its transactions with the stakeholders through providing timely and reliable reports (Maak, 2008). Restructuring aimed at corporate integrity allows implementing, instead of a relationship based on a linear and one-sided process in interaction with the stakeholders, a rotational and multi-tasking process, which encompasses a wide range of intra-organizational performances in order to meet the needs of stakeholders and investors aimed to create and develop their needs, and attempting to provide its information ad performances for the shareholders, investors, analysts, and legislators based on a strategic influence on the competitive market (Saifurrahman & Kassim, 2023). Strategic influence encompasses the company's interactive functions with stakeholders in a timely and reliable transfer of news and information.…”

Comparison of Credit Risk Management Practices among Islamic and Public Commercial Bank’s in Pakistan

“…The definition can be summed up in that way. Credit risk is assessed according to the severity of the effect, the probability of occurrence, and the controllability (Saifurrahman et al, 2022). Following the evaluation, financial institutions like banks are given instructions on how to comprehend the risk's chance of happening, its impact on the bank, and potential methods to deal with or control the risk.…”