Misconceived Causal Explanations for Emergent Processes

Abstract

Studies exploring how students learn and understand science processes such as diffusion and natural selection typically find that students provide misconceived explanations of how the patterns of such processes arise (such as why giraffes' necks get longer over generations, or how ink dropped into water appears to ''flow''). Instead of explaining the patterns of these processes as emerging from the collective interactions of all the agents (e.g., both the water and the ink molecules), students often explain the pattern as being caused by controlling agents with intentional goals, as well as express a variety of many other misconceived notions. In this article, we provide a hypothesis for what constitutes a misconceived explanation; why misconceived explanations are so prevalent, robust, and resistant to instruction; and offer one approach of how they may be overcome. In particular, we hypothesize that students misunderstand many science processes because they rely on a generalized version of narrative schemas and scripts (referred to here as a Direct-causal Schema) to interpret them. For science processes that are sequential and stage-like, such as cycles of moon, circulation of blood, stages of mitosis, and photosynthesis, a Direct-causal Schema is adequate for correct understanding. However, for science processes that are non-sequential (or emergent), such as diffusion, natural selection, osmosis, and heat flow, using a Direct Schema to understand these processes will lead to robust misconceptions. Instead, a different type of general schema may be required to interpret non-sequential processes, which we refer to as an Emergent-causal Schema. We propose that students lack this Emergent Schema and teaching it to them may help them learn and understand emergent kinds of science processes such as diffusion. Our study found that directly teaching students this Emergent Schema led to increased learning of the process of diffusion. This article presents a fine-grained characterization of each type of Schema, our instructional intervention, the successes we have achieved, and the lessons we have learned.Correspondence should be sent to Michelene T.

Biological Principles and Threshold Concepts for Understanding Natural Selection

“…Thus, introducing and emphasizing threshold concepts in parallel with key concepts in natural selection education may be essential, but this raises questions about the optimal way(s) to do this, which we address in the following sections. Natural selection is an extremely complex probabilistic phenomenon that involves random processes, or at least processes with varying degrees of stochasticity (e.g., mutation, mating, and accidental death) that lead to profound self-organizing and emergent changes in populations of organisms over vast (and diverse) scales of space and time (Chi et al 2012). The complexity is illustrated by the interactions among genetic changes, physiological and developmental processes involved in phenotypic expression, myriads of environmental factors, fitness, survival, and (hence) selection pressures, all of which involve highly complex processes and vary massively over space and time.…”

Toward Automatic Inference of Causal Structure in Student Essays

“…The other rule looks for dependencies between connectors and results, looking at 7 types of dependencies. 3 In fact, 25 -30% of the student essay sentences had an LSA cosine greater that 0.75 with some sentence from the relevant document set. Ironically, this facilitates our job of classifying the student sentences.…”

“…Student sentences associated with these items tend to bear a striking similarity to the original texts that they came from. 3 The machine learning techniques have had a much more difficult time identifying conceptual material related to inferences between documents. Examples of these items are rather infrequent in the students' essays (explaining why we need a system like this).…”

Teaching urbanism: the Delft approach

“…Designing in this complex landscape requires appropriate methods and tools that embrace the dynamic nature of the design object. This is a challenge, as students might have difficulties dealing with emergent processes (Chi et al, 2011). The development of dynamic design media, such as simple simulation models (i.e.…”