Minimalism, subjectivity, and aesthetics: rethinking the anti-aesthetic tradition in late-modern art

Abstract

Minimalism, Subjectivity and Aesthetics: Rethinking the Anti-Aesthetic Tradition in Late-modern Art.Minimalism is routinely interpreted as anti-subjective, anti-expressive and anti-aesthetic. This paper challenges this interpretation by closely examining two accounts of minimalism: Rosalind Krauss's article of 1973, "Sense and Sensibility," and Thierry de Duve's amplification and refutation of aspects of Krauss' argument in his 1983 article, "Performance Here and Now." Each believes that minimalism presents a model of subjectivity, and each produces an account of subjectivity that is both embedded in the work and yet produced by the viewer's interaction with it. Krauss and de Duve do not agree on the theory of the subject that Minimalism enacts, despite agreeing that a model of subjectivity is what is at stake in minimalist art.One can clearly see here the revival of Hegel's claim that the task of art is to "present man with himself" as well as a renewed focus on the nature of aesthetic reception. It is my contention that aesthetics allows us to see more clearly what is at stake in the refiguring of art that these two groundbreaking accounts of minimalism trace. Thus, although minimalism is often argued to mark the beginning of an anti-aesthetic tradition in art practice and art criticism, its radical achievements are best understood through aesthetics.This crucial link between subjectivity and late-modern art has been all but lost in the subsequent literature. A phenomenological approach to minimalism, such as Krauss's, is now simply shorthand for attending to the motile and perceptual experience of art and its context. This approach is then neatly historicised and believed to be dispatched by subsequent art with a more politically attuned concern for context. To resuscitate her theoretical concern with models of subjectivity, as De Duve does, upsets this foreclosure, while also creating an opening for other ways to trace the progress of late-modern art-the overall aim of my paper.In a recent round table discussion on conceptual art and the reception of Duchamp, Thierry de Duve asked the following provocative question: 'Does anybody really believe there is such a thing as the elimination of subjectivity [in art]? (October 1994: 140) Immediately prior to this question, Alexander Alberro had been explaining how the minimalist artist Donald Judd contributed to the dismantling of the time-honoured link between subjectivity 127 JVAP 5 (3) 127-142

Detection of Emotions in Artworks Using a Convolutional Neural Network Trained on Non-Artistic Images: A Methodology to Reduce the Cross-Depiction Problem

“…The poor performance of contemporary art can be explained by the works contained in this category, which in the WikiArt Emotion Dataset include minimalist paintings. This type of artwork is characterized by elimination of aesthetics, subjectivity, and emotion by the artist (Best, 2006; Wolff, 2005), with only the “purest” elements remaining, and a predominance of orderly geometric shapes. These artworks are thus already simplified, so that after applying the QuickShift algorithm from our methodology they become oversimplified, providing very different results by comparison with other art categories.…”

“…Minimalist art is also characterized by its integration and interaction with the exposition space (Best, 2006), which is an impediment for the model presented in this study since two-dimensional images were used for training. Detecting emotions in three-dimensional space is an unknown challenge in computational analysis (Zhao et al, 2022).…”

Goodbye materialism: exploring antecedents of minimalism and its impact on millennials well-being

“…The visual arts and design are also influenced by minimalism. To achieve a harmony between man-made architecture (Zafarmand et al, 2003 ) and the environment, minimalist architects frequently combine nature and the interior (Best, 2006 ). Tadao Ando, a Japanese architect, is a leading example of a modern architect who practises minimalism.…”

The Mutual Influence between Asian Cultures and American Minimalist Music: An Essential Channel for Aesthetic Exchange

“…Within "Fluxus", several artists developed an interest in Zen, like Cage, La Monte Young, or the influential New York art critic Arthur C. Danto (b. 1924) who was inspired by Zen Buddhist Ching Yuan (Best, 2006). La Monte Young explores the connections of "Fluxus" between the arts, sound, and music in the 1970s.…”