Militants of Truth, Communities of Equality: Badiou and the ignorant schoolmaster

Abstract

Badiou's philosophy of the 'event' has itself become an event of sorts for contemporary social and political theory. It has broken radically with a set of propositions concerning the operation of power, the status of knowledge, and the possibility of action that were for some time considered nearly unquestionable, in many ways defining what Badiou might call 'the state of the situation'. After briefly outlining the manner in which Badiou's reinvigoration of the concept of 'truth' constitutes a serious challenge for the politics of difference and the ethics of alterity, this paper explores the significance for educational philosophy of what, borrowing from Jacques Rancière, Badiou calls the 'axiom of equality', or the notion that, in democratic politics, 'equality must be postulated not willed'. I suggest that this axiom is best understood when read in relation to Rancière's The Ignorant Schoolmaster, and thus explore an intrinsic link between Badiou's more obscure philosophical claims and political assertions on the one hand, and the question of education on the other. I further propose that the limitations of Badiou's criticism of Rancière's work, which suggests that he stops short of locating an effective political subject who might oppose the parliamentary state, are revealed most explicitly when we reassess Rancière's approach to education in The Ignorant Schoolmaster, and in his more recent work on political aesthetics. Ultimately, however, I conclude that a truly democratic approach to education will have to learn from both Badiou and Rancière, and take seriously the 'axiom of equality'.

What Can We Learn from Art Practices? Exploring New Perspectives on Critical Engagement with Plurality and Difference in Community Art Education

“…In either case, equality can neither be planned nor accomplished. It can only be practiced and through this practice verified’ (Barbour , 255).…”

Without Criteria: Art and Learning and the Adventure of Pedagogy

“…Finally, the question of aesthetics, which for Rancière () lies at the core of politics. For Rancière, aesthetics is concerned with ‘what it means to perceive and experience the world not what it means to create or appreciate works of art’ (Barbour , 261). He is interested in those disruptions of habitual or normalising modes of practice: those ways of speaking and acting that effect new distributions of the sensible that lead to new modes of speaking and acting.…”

Learning, Work and Practice: New Understandings

“…Charles Barbour ( 2010 ) succinctly summarizes Badiou's main moves in this regard: Charles Barbour ( 2010 ) succinctly summarizes Badiou's main moves in this regard:…”