Secondary deuterium isotope elTects have been measured for the reactions between methy1 and methyl-da iodides and a series of tertiary amines in benzene solvent. Deuteriuin substitution increased the rate of each reaction but the rate ratios ( k~/ k~) show no systematic change with variation in the structure of the amine. The isotope elfect for the reaction with 2-picoline was measured a t different telnperatures over a range of 40 deg and shows no change. These isotope effects may be rationalized a s internal rotational effects of the methyl group or a s solvation erects.h h n y of the kinetic secondary deuterium isotope effects recorded in the literature have been nleasured in reaction systenls in which solvation of the reaction site is a n important, but relatively unlinown, factor. For such systems it is very difficult to assess what part of the isotopic rate change is due to solvation phenomena and what part colues about as a result of internal changes in the reacting molecule. Investigations of the dependence of secondary isotope effect on solvent composition give no clear answer to this problem. Shiner and Verbanic (1) found that isotope effects produced by a-deuteration of the alkyl group in p-alkyl benzhydryl chlorides solvolyzillg in aqueous acetone were marlcedly dependent on the water content of the solvent, although the isotopic rate ratios were all quite close to unity. For a-deuterated methyl and ethyl p-bromobenzenesulfonates, Lewis and co-~vorlrers (2) found only very small changes in the isotope effect between the two solvents, methanol and acetic acid, ~v h i c l~ they interpreted on the basis of a difference in mechanism of reaction rather than a direct solvation difference. Similar changes in isotope effect, presumably due to mechanism changes, were observed by Lewis and Boozer (3) in the solvolysis reactions of 2-pentyl-1,1,1,3,3,dj-p-toluenesulfonate in acetic acid, formic acid, and 80% aqueous ethanol. Similar results were observed by Winstein and Talrahashi (4) for 3-methyl-2-butyl-3d-9-toluenesulfonate solvolyzing in the same solvents.Thus changing the solvent gives information concerning solvation isotope effects which is not separable fro111 information concerning effects resulting from changes in mechanism. Apart from the deuterated p-allryl benzhydryl chlorides, there is no clear change of isotope effect with solvent for which there is not a t least the possibility of a mechanistic change.Recently, Leffelr, Robertson, and Sugamori (5) proposed that the @-deuteriuln isotope effects in the water solvolyses of isopropyl compounds, which are rate changes brought about by changes in the entropy of activation, were due to differences in the barriers to rotation of the methyl and 111ethyl-d3 groups and differences in these barriers between the initial arid transition states of the reaction. Although a reasonably large part of the observed effect could be accounted for on this theory, the uniinportance of solv a t' ion a s the source of the effect was not proved. I-Ialevi and co-wor...