Microstructural alterations in tract development in college football: a longitudinal diffusion MRI study

Abstract

Background and Objectives: Repeated concussive and sub-concussive impacts in high-contact sports can affect microstructure of the brain, which can be studied using diffusion MRI. Most prior imaging studies, however, employ a cross-sectional design, do not include low-contact players as controls, or use traditional diffusion tensor imaging without investigating novel tract-specific microstructural metrics. Methods: We examined brain microstructure in 63 high-contact (American football) and 34 low-contact (volleyball) collegiate athletes with up to 4 years of follow-up (315 total scans) using advanced diffusion MRI, a comprehensive set of multi-compartment models, and automated fiber quantification tools. We investigated diffusion metrics along the length of tracts using nested linear mixed-effects models to ascertain the acute and chronic effects of sub-concussive and concussive impacts, as well as associations between diffusion changes with clinical, behavioral, and sports-related measures. Results: Significant longitudinal increases in fractional anisotropy and axonal water fraction were detected in volleyball players, but not in football players, along with decreases in radial and mean diffusivity as well as orientation dispersion index (all findings absolute T-statistic > 3.5, p < .0001). This pattern was present in the callosum forceps minor, left superior longitudinal fasciculus, left thalamic radiation, and right cingulum hippocampus. Longitudinal group differences were more prominent and observed in a larger number of tracts in concussed (previously or in-study) football players (p < .0001), while smaller effects were noted in un-concussed players. An analysis of immediate-post concussion scans in football players demonstrated a transient localized increase in axial diffusivity, mean and radial kurtosis in the left uncinate and right cingulum hippocampus (p < .0001). Finally, football players with high position-based sub-concussive risk demonstrated increased orientation dispersion index over time (p < .0001). Discussion: The observed longitudinal changes in our volleyball cohort likely reflect normal development in this age range, while the relative attenuation of these effects seen in football, and especially concussed athletes, could possibly reveal diminished myelination, altered axonal calibers, or depressed pruning processes leading to a static, non-decreasing axonal dispersion. This prospective longitudinal study demonstrates significantly divergent tract-specific trajectories of brain microstructure, possibly reflecting a concussive and/or repeated sub-concussive impact-related alteration of normal white matter development in football athletes.

Mind Your Head

“…In this issue of Neurology ®, Goubran et al 1 publish a study in which they assessed white matter fiber tract integrity using a 3-Tesla advanced diffusion imaging sequence in 2 groups of collegiate athletes involved in high-contact (football; n = 49; mean age = 19.11) and low-contact (volleyball; n = 24; age = 19.57) sports. Participants completed questionnaires and underwent imaging at the beginning of the athletic season and at multiple follow-up time points scheduled over a period of 4 years.…”