Methods used to examine technology in relation to the quality of nursing work in acute care: A systematic integrative review

Abstract

Aims and objectives:To systematically locate, assess and synthesise research to describe methods used to examine technology in relation to the quality of nursing work in acute care. Specific objectives were to (a) describe the types of nursing work examined; (b) describe methods used to examine technology in nursing work; (c) identify outcomes used to evaluate technology in relation to the quality of nursing work; and (d) make recommendations for future research.Background: New technologies can offer numerous benefits to nurses; however, it is challenging to evaluate health information technologies in relation to the quality of nurses' complex day-to-day work.Design: A systematic integrative review using a five-step process.Methods: Five databases were searched using search terms "nurs*," "workload," "task," "time." Data screening, extraction and interpretation were conducted independently by at least two authors and agreement verified by discussion. Data extraction followed PRISMA guidelines. Results:Of the 41 studies included, most (87.8%, n = 36) examined physical dimensions of nursing work; 31.7% (n = 13) organisational dimensions; 17.1% (n = 8) cognitive dimensions; and only 12.2% (n = 5) emotional dimensions. More than half (58.5%, n = 24) examined only one dimension; one captured all four dimensions. Most frequently examined technologies were electronic medical/health records (36.5%) and electronic medication management (19.5%). Direct observation (58.8%, n = 28) and multiple methods (19.5%, n = 8) were the most common methods; nurse tasks, frequency, duration and time distribution were variables most often measured. Conclusions: Examinations of technology in nursing work often failed to capture the multiple dimensions of this work nor did they recognise the complexity of day-to-day nursing work in acute care. There is a paucity of literature to inform how and what technology should be measured in relation to the quality of nursing care. Relevance to clinical practice: The outcomes inform useful research methods to comprehensively examine technology to enhance the quality of complex nursing work. K E Y W O R D S integrative review, methods, nursing, quality of care, technology S U PP O RTI N G I N FO R M ATI O N Additional supporting information may be found online in the Supporting Information section. How to cite this article: Redley B, Douglas T, Botti M. Methods used to examine technology in relation to the quality of nursing work in acute care: A systematic integrative review. J

Tecnologia gerencial para implementação da Sistematização da Assistência de Enfermagem

“…Tal tecnologia materializa de maneira palpável os elementos e requisitos essenciais para que tal gestão se torne cotidiana nos serviços e que seja capaz de dirimir dúvidas entre a categoria trabalhadora sobre "o que é" e "o que não é" a SAE (7,8) . Neste sentido, sob esta situação, a literatura científica tem apontado a carência de TG focadas no trabalho em enfermagem, principalmente em alguns cenários, como aqueles de produção de cuidados agudos, que envolvem múltiplas dimensões e complexidades no trabalho diário de profissionais de enfermagem (24) . Portanto, reforça a utilidade e pertinência do nosso estudo.…”

Technological innovation for workload allocation in nursing care management: an integrative review

“…Lack of reliability and interruptions impeded its use. The challenge for workload estimation and prediction systems is having adequate information about the time and effort needed for nursing care activities, considering the interactions and iterations of the day-to-day care process, in physical, cognitive, organizational, and emotional dimensions (Redley et al, 2020). The variability in the patient care process usually has significant skewness.…”

“…The impact of technology for predicting nurse workload and deciding optimal staffing levels includes factors such as quality of care, patient safety, staff turnover and satisfaction, and process efficiency. Understanding nurses work is essential to assessing how technologies contribute to quality of care (Redley et al, 2020). There has been insufficient discussion of how technologies can be used to correlate operational cost with quality of care (Griffiths et al, 2020).…”

“…The most studied technologies in ICUs (intensive care unit) were electronic medical records (EMR) and electronic medication management (Redley et al, 2020). Nursing-specific information systems, general computer, communication technologies and electronic data analysis being less often studied.…”

“…Current technology to assess the nursing workload doesn't capture the complexity or quality of care, and doesn't recognize the concurrent, iterative, and interrelated nature of cognitive processes and activities in nursing. Therefore, there is a gap in the literature on how technology affects the quality of nursing care and how to measure it (Redley et al, 2020).…”