Methods for calculating PNECs using species sensitivity distribution (SSD) with various hypothesis on the way to handle ecotoxicity data

Abstract

Species sensitivity distribution (SSD) methodology is currently used to determine the Predicted No Effect Concentration (PNEC) of a substance, considering chronic ecotoxicological tests on three taxonomic groups: algae, invertebrates and vertebrates (aquatic environment). However, SSD methodology raises some practical questions due to the multiple possibilities of handling the available data. In particular the following points are often discussed: (1) how to take into account the intra-species variation; (2) how to handle heterogeneous repartition of available data among the taxonomic groups; (3) could we use the information contained in acute data, and how, in the construction of SSDs; (4) when only a limited number of data is available, how is it possible to build relevant SSDs. Different approaches have been tested in answer to each of these questions: For questions (1) and (2): different methods were compared, each of them being characterized by a different way of taking into account intra-species variation and proportions of taxonomic groups (vertebrates, invertebrates and algae), as well as by the actual method of calculation of the HC5 (Hazardous Concentration) and its confidence interval. These different methods were compared for 15 substances using NOEC data available in the literature and the uncertainty associated to the data treatment was quantified. For question (3): an "Acute-to-Chronic Transformation" (ACT) function was derived and a methodology for the incorporation of acute data in the construction of SSDs was tested. This ACT method was tested on 11 substances: for each substance, the actual chronic SSD was compared to the predicted SSD derived from the incorporation of transformed acute data. For question (4): Bayesian methods were tested to build SSDs from limited datasets and the relevance of such methods was discussed. Various approaches are suggested here in answer to each of these three questions. They have been combined in a comprehensive overview to define alternative strategies according to the availability of ecotoxicological data.

Hardness-Dependent Water Quality Criteria for Protection of Freshwater Aquatic Organisms for Silver in China

“…The SSD method is based on the assumption that the species being tested is representative of all the species in the ecosystem as far as sensitivity is concerned. It has been shown that the SSD method has the advantages of being supported by statistical theory and being able to use a full array of toxicological data [34]. Therefore, the SSD method might be an effective tool to apply to derive the WQC for silver to protect freshwater aquatic organisms in China.…”