Methodological Issues in Population-Based Studies of Multigenerational Associations

Abstract

<jats:title>Abstract</jats:title> <jats:p>Laboratory-based animal research has revealed a number of exposures with multigenerational effects—ones that affect the children and grandchildren of those directly exposed. An important task for epidemiology is to investigate these relationships in human populations. Without the relative control achieved in laboratory settings, however, population-based studies of multigenerational associations have had to use a broader range of study designs. Current strategies to obtain multigenerational data include exploiting birth registries and existing cohort studies, ascertaining exposures within them and measuring outcomes across multiple generations. In this paper, we describe the methodological challenges inherent to multigenerational studies in human populations. After outlining standard taxonomy to facilitate discussion of study designs and target exposure associations, we highlight the methodological issues, focusing on the interplay between study design, analysis strategy, and the fact that outcomes may be related to family size. In a simulation study, we show that different multigenerational designs lead to estimates of different exposure associations with distinct scientific interpretations. Nevertheless, target associations can be recovered by incorporating (possibly) auxiliary information, and we provide insights into choosing an appropriate target associations. Finally, we identify areas requiring further methodological development.</jats:p>

Smoking During Pregnancy and Risk of Attention-deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder in the Third Generation

“…To account for the potentially informative clustering based on possible effects of smoking on number of children born alive, 18 we calculated odds ratios (ORs) for ADHD related to grandmother smoking using all grandchildren with cluster-weighted generalized estimating equation (CW-GEE) regression models with a logit link, weighted by the inverse of the number of children of each nurse (G1). 19,20 Because of the concern of unmeasured confounding in the association between maternal smoking and child ADHD, and that these could also apply to grand-maternal smoking, we took several approaches to explore the possibility of unmeasured confounding. We considered maternal smoking and elements of dose-response by considering the number of cigarettes smoked per day by the grandmother and the grandfather's smoking.…”

The Impact of Early-Life Exposures on Women’s Reproductive Health in Adulthood

“…These concerns are magnified in multigenerational studies. Technological developments in both statistical methods [ 75 ] and epigenetics [ 79 ] will be needed to improve our understanding of patterns of disease and of mechanisms. However, given the lack of efficacy for many interventions implemented during pregnancy, improving health in this crucial period may not be possible without improving health throughout life.…”

“…For some, the focus is on change in risk factors across generations, particularly those with a focus on social or neighborhood exposures [ 18 , 19 ]. All the study designs share issues with completeness of measurement across generations and informative missing data [ 75 ]. Interpretation of these studies is additionally complex in that it is generally easier to follow the maternal line, but many epigenetic and transgenerational effects in both humans and animals have been shown to be paternal [ 76 ].…”

Exploring the evidence for epigenetic regulation of environmental influences on child health across generations

“…Moreover, there may be ethical concerns about using samples from subjects whose informed consent was provided years or decades ago and may not directly address these types of assays in biospecimens. Furthermore, different study designs and/or analysis strategies can lead to different conclusions from the data 243 .…”