Production of animal
protein is associated with high greenhouse
gas (GHG) emissions. Globally, oyster aquaculture is increasing as
a way to meet growing demands for protein, yet its associated GHG-emissions
are largely unknown. We quantified oyster aquaculture GHG-emissions
from the three main constituents of GHG-release associated with terrestrial
livestock production: fermentation in the animal gut, manure management,
and fodder production. We found that oysters release no methane (CH4) and only negligible amounts of nitrous oxide (0.00012 ±
0.00004 μmol N2O gDW–1 hr–1) and carbon dioxide (3.556 ± 0.471 μmol CO2 gDW–1 hr–1). Further, sediment
fluxes of N2O and CH4 were unchanged in the
presence of oyster aquaculture, regardless of the length of time it
had been in place. Sediment CO2 release was slightly stimulated
between 4 and 6 years of aquaculture presence and then returned to
baseline levels but was not significantly different between aquaculture
and a control site when all ages of culture were pooled. There is
no GHG-release from oyster fodder production. Considering the main
drivers of GHG-release in terrestrial livestock systems, oyster aquaculture
has less than 0.5% of the GHG-cost of beef, small ruminants, pork,
and poultry in terms of CO2-equivalents per kg protein,
suggesting that shellfish aquaculture may provide a a low GHG alternative
for future animal protein production compared to land based sources.
We estimate that if 10% of the protein from beef consumption in the
United States was replaced with protein from oysters, the GHG savings
would be equivalent to 10.8 million fewer cars on the road.