“…Net oxidation rates of the long-incubation treatments at 10× (46 days) and 200× (41 days) methane concentration fall into the mid-range of rates published for Arctic and subarctic environments (Damm et al, 2015;Gentz et al, 2014;Lorenson et al, 2016;Mau et al, 2013Mau et al, , 2017Steinle et al, 2015) or marine sites with high oxidation rates at oil spills or gas flares (Leonte et al, 2017;Redmond et al, 2010;Valentine et al, 2010), as discussed in Uhlig and Loose (2017a). The fractionation factors (α ox ) that we observed are higher than previously reported from cold marine environments with a range of α ox from 1.002 to 1.017 (Cowen et al, 2002;Damm et al, 2008;Grant and Whiticar, 2002;Heeschen et al, 2004;Keir et al, 2009;Tsunogai et al, 2000). However, some of these fractionation factors, which were calculated from in situ data, might be underestimates due to mixing effects in the water column (Grant and Whiticar, 2002).…”