Meta-analysis: A useful tool to assess infection prevalence and disease ecology of Borrelia burgdorferi sensu lato in nymphal ticks in North-Western Europe with recommendations for a standardised approach to future studies

Walsh, Rita G.; Gormally, M.; Zintl, Annetta; Carlin, C.

doi:10.1016/j.parepi.2022.e00254

Cited by 4 publications

(1 citation statement)

References 49 publications

(133 reference statements)

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…Modelling studies performed by Robinson et al [30] for pathogens and by Li et al [31] for ticks and pathogens corroborated these empirical ndings. However, this statement must be nuanced as several authors also found co-dependant effects for the vector presence [32,33] and for the pathogen presence with the meta-analysis of Walsh et al [34]. Our scoping review emphasized that forests may protect against disease transmission under speci c conditions involving forest con guration factors as shown in the studies of Dong et al [35] and Wongnak et al [36].…”

Section: Forest Effects and The Uence Of Ecological Backgroundmentioning

confidence: 74%

A scoping review of the impacts of forest dynamics on acari-borne diseases: beyond forest fragmentation

Blache,

Chalvet-Monfray,

Déprés

et al. 2024

Preprint

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Background: Forest cover has undergone significant changes, which have accelerated over recent decades. Acari vectors such as ticks and chigger mites are intricately linked to forest ecosystems because of the suitable hosts and microclimates they provide. However, the implications of forest cover change and dynamics on acari vectors and their pathogens remain poorly understood. This study aims to investigate the impacts of forest dynamics on the risk of acari-borne diseases worldwide through a comprehensive review of the literature. Methods: We conducted a scoping review following the PRISMA Method to retrieve citations related to forest dynamics and acari-borne diseases. Eligibility criteria were predefined and relevant data were extracted from selected articles. The analysis employed a descriptive approach and thematic narrative synthesis. Results: Our review reveals that the influence of forest dynamics on acari-borne diseases and related vectors was predominantly discussed within a Western context, particularly with regard to Ixodes ticks and Lyme disease. Four types of forest dynamics have been identified in the literature: deforestation, fragmentation, conversion and reforestation. However, there was no consensus on the impacts of those dynamics on the vectors and their associated pathogens. Studies have reported conflicting findings including: protective or risk effects, nonlinear relationships, dependent effects influenced by additional factors altering relationships or nonsignificant effects. Those outcomes had been reported across different forest dynamics and various locations. Although, there is limited empirical evidence on tropical contexts as well as for reforestation and conversion dynamics, making it difficult to draw conclusions regarding pathogen and vector trends. Differences in results trends emerge when comparing the entire article sample (n = 111) to empirical studies (n = 73), with literature reviews often overestimating the dilution effect observed in empirical research. Finally, our review identifies a notable absence of studies on scrub typhus disease in the context of forest dynamics. Conclusions: This scoping review offers a novel and comprehensive overview of global literature on the impacts of forest dynamics on acari vectors and the infectious agents they transmit. It highlights research gaps and the need for future research targeting specific forest dynamics, particularly chigger mite vectors in a tropical context.

show abstract