Mental health training programmes for non-mental health trained professionals coming into contact with people with mental ill health: a systematic review of effectiveness

Abstract

BackgroundThe police and others in occupations where they come into close contact with people experiencing/with mental ill health, often have to manage difficult and complex situations. Training is needed to equip them to recognise and assist when someone has a mental health issue or learning/intellectual disability. We undertook a systematic review of the effectiveness of training programmes aimed at increasing knowledge, changing behaviour and/or attitudes of the trainees with regard to mental ill health, mental vulnerability, and learning disabilities.MethodsDatabases searched from 1995 onwards included: ASSIA, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Clinical Trials (CENTRAL), Criminal Justice Abstracts, Embase, ERIC, MEDLINE, PsycINFO, Social Science Citation Index. Courses, training, or learning packages aimed at helping police officers and others who interact with the public in a similar way to deal with people with mental health problems were included. Primary outcomes were change in practice and change in outcomes for the groups of people the trainees come into contact with. Systematic reviews, randomised controlled trials (RCTs) and non- randomised controlled trials (non-RCTs) were included and quality assessed. In addition non-comparative evaluations of training for police in England were included.ResultsFrom 8578 search results, 19 studies met the inclusion criteria: one systematic review, 12 RCTs, three prospective non-RCTs, and three non-comparative studies.The training interventions identified included broad mental health awareness training and packages addressing a variety of specific mental health issues or conditions. Trainees included police officers, teachers and other public sector workers.Some short term positive changes in behaviour were identified for trainees, but for the people the trainees came into contact with there was little or no evidence of benefit.ConclusionsA variety of training programmes exist for non-mental health professionals who come into contact with people who have mental health issues. There may be some short term change in behaviour for the trainees, but longer term follow up is needed. Research evaluating training for UK police officers is needed in which a number of methodological issues need to be addressed.Trial registration Protocol registration number: PROSPERO: CRD42015015981.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12888-017-1356-5) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Investigating police officers' perceptions of their role in pathways to mental healthcare

“…A recent review of the effectiveness of mental health training programmes for police officers was unable to conclude the best approach due to huge variations and poor quality of evidence (Booth et. al, ). This review, however, suggested that training delivered by mental health professionals involving acting or role‐play can be particularly beneficial.…”

“…Police officers' mental health training should assist decision‐making in these situations (Booth et. al, ). However, officers regard mental health training as inadequate (Vermette, Pinals, & Appelbaum, ; Wells & Schafer, ).…”

Mental Health in the UK Police Force: a Qualitative Investigation into the Stigma with Mental Illness

“…Regrettably, due to the lack of mental health training within police forces (Cummings and Jones 2010), additional training is required in order to change attitudes towards mental health (Booth et al 2017;Soomro and Yanos 2018). Addressing these attitudes starts at a managerial level (Bell and Eski 2016).…”

Police-related triage interventions for mental health-related incidents: a rapid evidence synthesis

“…Initial scoping work identified five systematic reviews that described and evaluated PRMHTs. 11,[15][16][17][18] In addition, a number of non-systematic literature reviews also described relevant intervention models. [19][20][21][22] The existing reviews incorporated overlapping literature searches, the most recent of which was completed in June 2016.…”

“…31 This resulted in five reviews being included in the synthesis. 11,12,14,15,39,40 There were six articles published for the five reviews as Kane et al 11 also published their review protocol. The remaining 25 review articles were excluded from the synthesis as their methods were deemed less robust (according to DARE criteria) or were not reported.…”