Mental health practitioner experiences of engaging with service users in community mental health settings: A systematic review and thematic synthesis of qualitative evidence

Abstract

Accessible summary What is known on the subject? Engagement is regarded as important and beneficial for service users and mental health services A universal definition of engagement is not yet fully agreed upon. What this paper adds to existing knowledge? Based upon their experience, mental health staff use varied engagement approaches to fit with the changeable and unique needs of people who use services (service users). Mental health staff demonstrate qualities such as persistence and adaptability to successfully engage with service users. What are the implications for practice? Irrespective of professional background, the role of community mental health staff is not restricted to any single approach. Practical help and social support are as seen as important as clinical treatment to establish successful engagement. Little is known about the engagement experiences of mental health staff working in early intervention settings as most studies in this review focused on the perspectives of staff based in assertive outreach or community mental health teams. There is a need to further understand staff experiences of engagement with service users in early intervention settings. Role descriptions and expectations of community mental health workers should account for the wide‐ranging flexible approach required in order to deliver appropriate interventions. This may involve a focus on engagement in training programmes. Abstract IntroductionEffective mental health care is dependent on engaging service users, but some individuals do not actively attend appointments, and may stop engaging with mental health services. Quantitative studies reveal some salient factors that seem to predict engagement, but these studies miss the nuances of good clinical practice in this area. A number of qualitative studies of health professionals' experiences and understanding of effective engagement have been published. AimThis review aimed to systematically identify, evaluate and synthesize results from these studies with a view to informing effective practice in this area. MethodsElectronic databases MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, PsychINFO and AMED were searched (PROSPERO systematic review protocol registry (http://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/; ID CRD42017083976). Of 799 records, ten papers met the inclusion criteria. All papers were subjected to quality appraisal based on the CASP checklist and data systematically extracted. A thematic synthesis of included studies examining mental health practitioners' experiences of engagement in community mental health settings was conducted. ResultsMental health practitioners see engaging service users as depending upon complex, multi‐dimensional phenomena which should include individualized person‐centred approaches as well as practical, social and clinical support. Mental health practitioners demonstrate qualities such as determination and adaptability to establish and maintain engagement with service users. Implications for practiceAs a core aspect of nurse education, registered mental health ...

Psychiatric nurse's perceptions of their interactions with people who hear voices: A qualitative systematic review and thematic analysis

“…Nurses also said that that some service users were unwilling to sit and interact with them. They may have been suspicious of nurses due to their mental illness, or perhaps embarrassed at disclosing their voice hearing experience, not an unusual observation (Henderson et al, 2020). It has also been said by Molin et al (2016) that the obstruction or absence of such interactions with nursing staff can reinforce the perception of a stigmatizing environment and unclear content of care.…”

Experiences and challenges faced by community mental health workers when providing care to people with mental illness: a qualitative study

“…Several key areas were identified in this study. Among them, CMHWs are often ambivalent and ambiguous about their role in CMHS [46,47]. Communities in Western countries have teams of mental health services staffed by professional mental health nurses, psychiatrists, and psychologists [23][24][25].…”

Service intensity of community mental health outreach among people with untreated mental health problems in Japan: A retrospective cohort study

“…Community mental health outreach teams in the local public sector play a role in reaching out to untreated populations 16 . These teams are typically multidisciplinary and deliver various types of services to people in their homes, public spaces, or other settings 16,17 . Such services include connecting people to existing medical and social resources in the community, as well as treating psychiatric symptoms and providing assistance with daily living and with decision‐making about treatment and other issues 16 .…”

“…16 These teams are typically multidisciplinary and deliver various types of services to people in their homes, public spaces, or other settings. 16 , 17 Such services include connecting people to existing medical and social resources in the community, as well as treating psychiatric symptoms and providing assistance with daily living and with decision‐making about treatment and other issues. 16 According to systematic reviews, several models of community mental health outreach are effective in reducing the duration and frequency of psychiatric hospital admissions, 18 , 19 alleviating psychiatric symptoms, 18 , 20 and achieving other outcomes.…”