Mental Disorder—The Need for an Accurate Definition

Abstract

There are several reasons why a definition for mental disorder is essential. Among these are not only reasons linked to psychiatry itself as a science (nosology, research) but also to ethical, legal, and financial issues. The first formal definition of mental disorder resulted from a deep conceptual analysis led by Robert Spitzer. It emerged to address several challenges that psychiatry faced at the time, namely to serve as the starting point for an atheoretical and evidence-based classification of mental disorders, to justify the removal of homosexuality from classifications, and to counter the arguments of antipsychiatry. This definition has been updated, with some conceptual changes that make it depart from the main assumptions of Spitzer’s original definition. In this article, we intend to review the factors that substantiated the emergence of the first formal definition of mental disorder that based all its later versions.

Lateral Habenula Gone Awry in Depression: Bridging Cellular Adaptations With Therapeutics

“…Depression is a mental condition with a long-standing history. Already during the ancient Greek period, Hippocrates described “ Melancholia ” as a condition associated with “aversion to food, despondency, sleeplessness, irritability, restlessness.” Nowadays, the Diagnostic and Statistical manual of Mental disorders (DSM) defines major depression as a condition with persistent, unreactive low mood and a loss of interest in pleasure ( Telles-Correia et al, 2018 ). Such symptoms often occur in parallel with significant weight loss, sleep and psychomotor disturbances, fatigue and, in certain cases, recurrent thoughts of death or suicide.…”

Reintroducing Consciousness in Psychopathology: Review of the Literature and Conceptual Framework

“…Until recently distress and disability, as operationalization's of the criterion "harm, " were central in the definition of mental disorder. The DSM-5 changed this focus and gave priority to the concept of dysfunction (Telles-Correia et al, 2018). It defines a mental disorder as a syndrome characterized by a clinically significant disturbance in an individual's cognition, emotion regulation, or behavior, and reflecting a dysfunction in the psychological, biological, or developmental processes underlying mental functioning.…”

Bioethical aspects of assisted suicide and euthanasia in people suffering from mental health problems

“…Although there are various debates on defining mental disorders, it is generally accepted that they involve thought disorders, behavioral disorders, and emotional disorders serious enough to compromise people's functioning [10].…”