Certain pathogens recruit host complement inhibitors such as factor H (fH) to evade the immune system. Microbial complement inhibitor-binding molecules can be promising vaccine targets by eliciting antibodies that neutralize this microbial defense mechanism. One such antigen, meningococcal fH-binding protein (fHbp), was used in clinical trials before the protein was discovered to bind fH. The potential effect of fH binding on vaccine immunogenicity had not been assessed in experimental animals because fHbp binds human fH specifically. In this study, we developed a human fH transgenic mouse model. Transgenic mice immunized with fHbp vaccine had 4- to 8-fold lower serum bactericidal antibody responses than control mice whose native fH did not bind the vaccine. In contrast, antibody responses were unimpaired in transgenic mice immunized with a control meningococcal group C polysaccharide-protein conjugate vaccine. In transgenic mice, immunization with an fH non-binding mutant of fHbp elicited antibodies with higher bactericidal activity than fHbp vaccination itself. Antibodies elicited by the mutant fHbp more effectively blocked fH binding to wild-type fHbp than antibodies elicited by fHbp that bound fH. Thus, a mutant fHbp vaccine that does not bind fH, but which retains immunogenicity, is predicted to be superior in humans than an fHbp vaccine that binds human fH. In the case of mutant fHbp vaccination, the resultant antibody responses may be directed more at epitopes in or near the fH-binding site, which result in greater complement-mediated serum bactericidal activity; these epitopes may be obscured when human fH is bound to the wild-type fHbp vaccine.