Membership in agricultural producer organizations and farm technical efficiency in Slovakia

Abstract

Research background: EU National Rural Development Programs (RDPs) support food chain organization, including the establishment of agricultural producer organizations (APOs) to assist the cooperation among small- and medium-sized farms and improve their performance.
 Purpose of the article: We assessed how membership in an APO affects technical efficiency in a sample of Slovak farms. We break down our results by the type of membership (non-members, long-term members, and members of newly established APOs, benefitting from the RDP support) and production specialization of farms (crops, livestock, unspecialized). We expected a positive effect of membership on farm performance, although with differences by production specialization.
 Methods: We analyzed cross-sectional data of 645 farms in Slovakia in 2014, when the 2007–2013 RDP support was over. We applied a DEA-based two-stage metafrontier approach. During the first stage, we estimated group-specific efficiency and calculated adjusted (target) values of inputs, given the outputs. During the second stage, we estimated the meta-technical efficiency of farms relative to the metafrontier derived from pooled adjusted inputs and outputs of farm groups by their membership within production specialization. The meta-efficiency indicates farm efficiency associated with membership in a producer organization. We examined the differences between meta-efficiency by membership groups by the Kruskal-Wallis and post hoc Dunn’s tests.
 Findings & Value added: Members of APOs were mainly large farms. Membership in newly established APOs, benefitting from of the RDP support, contributed significantly to higher technical efficiency of livestock and crop farms. Their performance was, however, affected by managerial and scale inefficiencies. Well-performing farms with good farm management had joined APOs already before the year 2007. However, the long-term APO membership did not improve farm technical efficiency significantly. Public support of farm cooperation should be designed to improve the governance, sustainability of the APO activities, and performance of their members.

Using nonradial metafrontier data envelopment analysis to evaluate the metatechnology and metafactor ratios for the Taiwanese hotel industry

“…For determining changes, the metafrontier was combined with the Malmquist index by Fei and Lin (2016), Azad et al (2017), O'Donnell et al (2017, Zhu et al (2018), andChao andLai (2019). The assumption of the metafrontier was also developed to be a multiple-stage framework by Lin et al (2012) and Bartova and Fandel (2020) to compare the technology gaps in different subprocesses. Moghaddas et al (2022) used the metafrontier to build a multi-period evaluation model.…”

“…O'Donnell et al (2008) defined an index, the metatechnology ratio (MTR), to reflect the potential of an individual group's technology to achieve best practice. Metafrontier DEA has been employed to evaluate technology gaps for multiple industries (Bartova & Fandel, 2020; Goyal et al, 2018; Villano & Tran, 2019) and has been extended and improved through the use of different assumptions. For instance, de Witte and Marques (2010) used the concept of the free disposal hull to create the metafrontier; Kounetas et al (2009) applied the metafrontier to decompose efficiency; and Hančlová and Melecký (2016) incorporated negative factors into the measurement of the metafrontier.…”

“…Walheer et al (2020) defined hotel types based on their star rating, and Nurmatov et al (2021) grouped hotels according to regions. Bartova and Fandel (2020), de Witte and Marques (2010), Goyal et al (2018), and Villano and Tran (2019) employed metafrontier DEA to evaluate the performance of industries by using a heterogeneous sample.…”

Social Globalisation and Efficiency of Microfinance Institutions Nexus: Empirical Evidence on Financial and Social Efficiency

“…This approach has been applied to numerous studies that examine efficiency (Bartova & Fandel, 2020;Kamarudin et al, 2013;Kamarudin et al, 2014;Hussain et al, 2020a;Hussain et al, 2020b;Sufian & Kamarudin, 2014a;and Sufian & Kamarudin, 2014b). The non-parametric DEA approach was applied in the first stage of the analysis process to investigate the efficiency of MFIs under the variable returns to scale (VRS) model, which was proposed by Banker et al (1984).…”

Agricultural revenue in Latvia, Lithuania, and Poland: An application of the LMDI decomposition

“…The variability in agricultural output is much more nuanced even in the case small countries are considered (Bartova & Fandel, P. 2020;Popp et al, 2018). Per Läänemets et al (2011), one can consider such factors as soil quality, agricultural technologies, irrigation regime and climatic conditions as precursors for changes in the crop output.…”