Tourism is a backbone for Yogyakarta's economy. However, the COVID-19 pandemic has a negative impact on the tourism industry due to mobility restriction as a precautionary measure to prevent the spread of COVID-19. On the other hand, the COVID-19 pandemic encourages the presence of quality tourism that meets COVID-19 health protocol standards. Besides, a study shows that there is a shift in the trend of tourists who want experience-based tourism activities in small groups due to COVID-19 pandemic. The aim of this research is identifying and analyzing quality tourism indicators using sustainable tourism approaches performed by Moana Bike Tour. Combined research approaches are chosen because of different data collection methods and analysis, with quantitative approach is through questionnaire to the Moana's customers and qualitative approach is through in-depth interview and field observation. Results of this research are quantitative indicators are used to measure the satisfaction of Moana's customers, while qualitative indicators are used to see sustainable tourism aspects in Moana Bike Tour packages. Almost all quantitative indicators show that Moana Bike Tour's services could fulfill the satisfaction of its customers. On the other hand, qualitative indicators are showing the efforts made by Moana Bike Tour to achieve the sustainable tourism aspects. It is found that quality tourism could be achieved with sustainable tourism approaches.