Meeting the challenge of China: the Vietnamese garment industry in the post MFA era

Abstract

Although China has diversified into sophisticated, higher value‐added exports, it is still a formidable competitor in global markets for basic labour‐intensive products. It is the world's largest exporting country of textiles and garments, the archetypical driver of industrial growth both in developed countries in the past and in most newly industrializing countries more recently. When the export restrictions under the Multi‐Fibre Arrangement (MFA) ended at the start of 2005, it was predicted that China would greatly increase its market shares at the expense of most competitors, except perhaps India. Vietnam has proved to be an effective competitor in the garment industry in markets where China is dominant. In this article, we investigate how key export‐oriented garment suppliers of Vietnam have been coping with competitive challenges in the post MFA era at a time when global buyers have been reorganizing their international production networks. We emphasize the influence of different global value chains on upgrading since Vietnamese suppliers switched to the US market after the implementation of the US Bilateral Trade Agreement in 2001. We note the uneven performance of Vietnamese garment suppliers, with some lagging behind others in upgrading and competitiveness, and their different responses to Vietnam's growing labour shortages. We base the article mainly on interviews conducted over the 2001–2008 period with garment companies and global buyers in Vietnam, Hong Kong and China.

Corporate Social Responsibility in Garment Sourcing Networks: Factory Management Perspectives on Ethical Trade in Sri Lanka

“…Price competition heightened from 2005 following the phasing-out of the quota-based global sourcing system under the Multi-Fiber Arrangement (an international trade agreement on textiles and clothing that ran from 1974-2004) (cf. Goto et al 2011). The aim was therefore to establish a differentiated form of competitive advantage founded on ethical manufacturing and to become recognised as a leader in terms of lack of child labour, high health and safety standards and the ratification of ILO Core Conventions (Goger, 2013).…”

Connecting Local Producers in Developing Countries to Regional and Global Value Chains

“…Those countries that have been most successful in upgrading efforts have managed to develop strong backward linkages into textile production and diversified forward linkages into multiple end-markets (Frederick & Gereffi, 2011;Goto et al, 2011;Staritz & Morris, 2013;Tokatli & Kizilgun, 2009). Upgrading generally requires a strong public and private commitment to developing the necessary human capital, as illustrated in Table 5. 11.…”

Challenges to the Cambodian Garment Industry in the Global Garment Value Chain

“…Upgrading in process or product must happen so that increased productivity levels absorb the rapidly increasing wage rates for this industry to develop sustainably. This phenomenon, however, is also observed in other countries such as Vietnam (Goto et al, 2009). …”

“…Although cost pressures are increasing from the Japanese market-oriented value chains, quality is still regarded as the most important element for production. The EU market is situated between the Japanese and US markets in relation to both levels of value added and order size (Goto et al, 2009). As the Japanese market requires high quality products, Japanese buyers place priority on maintaining quality and uniformity, and provide strong commitments to improving the technical capacity of local manufacturers, typically dispatching technicians.…”