Meditators’ Non-academic Definition of Mindfulness

Abstract

Objectives Mindfulness has been defined differently in academic scientific contexts and in Buddhist academic contexts. An under-studied area is that of lay (non-academic) theories of mindfulness. The goal of this article is to identify, organize, analyze in detail, and provide themes from the meditators’ definitions of mindfulness. Possible differences and similarities of the collected definitions of mindfulness with the scientific-academic definitions and with the academic-Buddhist definitions are also checked. Methods A qualitative and inductive thematic analysis on the definitions of mindfulness offered by the participants was carried out. Results The sample consisted of 326 meditators who offered a definition of mindfulness through an open question. Seven themes were identified: (1) mindfulness defined as attention/awareness; (2) mindfulness defined as a non-evaluative attitude; (3) mindfulness defined as strategy; (4) mindfulness defined from a theoretical analysis; (5) mindfulness defined as a psycho-affective-spiritual state; (6) mindfulness defined as personal development; and (7) lack of understanding of mindfulness. From these themes, it can be deduced that the definitions collected share more patterns of meaning with the scientific-academic definition of mindfulness than with the academic-Buddhist one. Conclusions The findings of this study provide new insights into the complexity and heterogeneity of the definition of mindfulness. What has been discovered may indicate the complexity of the mindfulness construct itself.

Creating Mindful Spaces: Educational Practices for Interior Design

“…As we navigate through the different domains in our lives, our capacity of awareness here and now with curiosity and without any judgment as to what we experience (Alvear et al, 2022), can allow the creation of mindful spaces. In this respect, mindful experiential learning can offer a skillful means for cultivating inclusivity both internally (within our minds) and externally (as we design spaces).…”

“…There have been numerous suggestions for the definition of mindfulness across disciplinary fields (Alvear et al, 2022). To define mindfulness, Gethin (2011) reminds us of the original translation of the Buddhist term sati , which “plays on aspects of remembering, recalling, reminding, and presence of mind” (p. 275).…”

“…Bishop et al (2004) proposed an operational definition with two components: first, “the self-regulation of attention so that it is maintained in the immediate experience,” thus focusing on the present, and second, the orientation of the mind, which is “characterized by curiosity, openness, and acceptance” (p. 232), encompassing non-judgment. A recent study by Alvear et al (2022) revealed that mindfulness as attention/awareness and as a non-evaluative attitude were the most common definitions provided by meditation practitioners.…”

Does Meditation Improve Cognition Through Sleep?

“…It is worth stating up front that the term 'mindfulness,' although very much in vogue in science and popular culture, eludes any concrete definition. There are indeed several ongoing scholarly debates, that are all attempting to address what this term really means in the context of meditation (Alvear et al, 2022;Anālayo, 2019;Chiesa, 2013;Gethin, 2011;Nilsson & Kazemi, 2016). The confusion here is not totally unwarranted, as there are many ways one can appropriately use the term 'mindfulness': it can refer to the awareness of certain thoughts, feelings, or objects in one's experience (being mindful 'of' something); it can be used to denote a certain open attitude, or accepting posture towards aspects of one's experience (mindfulness 'as acceptance'); it can refer to a specific feeling, or a collection of feelings, e.g.…”

The Relationship Between Mindfulness and Impulsivity: The Role of Meditation

“…Although there have been studies that show mindfulness and impulsivity to be generally negatively correlated (Lattimore et al, 2011;Murphy & MacKillop, 2012;Peters et al, 2011;Rajesh et al, 2013), few studies have reported positive correlations between them (Lu & Huffman, 2017;Vinci et al, 2016;Wittmann et al, 2015). These inconclusive findings emphasize the difficulties of operationalizing both mindfulness (Alvear et al, 2022;Bergomi et al, 2013;Somaraju et al, 2023) and impulsivity and the necessity to examine the relationship between them from a multidimensional point of view and to qualify the findings according to the specific components being measured (Peters et al, 2011). This would broaden and deepen an examination of the relationship between these traits, which can vary at the subcomponent level.…”