Medieval Canon Lawyers and European Legal Tradition. A Brief Overview

Abstract

The Roman Church was a leading public institution of the Middle Ages and its law, canon law, belonged to most powerful factors of European legal history. Today’s lawyers have hardly any awareness of the canonist origins of several current legal institutions. Together with Roman law, canon law constituted the system of “both laws” (utrumque ius) which were the only laws acknowledged as “learned” and, consequently, taught at medieval universities. The dualism of secular (imperium) and spiritual power (sacerdotium), symbolized by so-called two swords doctrine, conferred to the Western legal tradition its balance and stability. We analyze the most important institutional achievements of the medieval canon lawyers: acquisitive prescription, the Roman-canonical procedure, the theory of just war, marriage and family law, freedom of contract, the inheritance under will, juristic personality, some institutions of constitutional law, in particular those based on the concept of representation, and finally commercial law. Last not least, the applicability of canon law defined the territorial extension of medieval and early modern Christian civilization which exceeded by far the borders of the Holy Roman Empire, where Roman law was effective as the law of the ruler. Hence, the first scholar to associate Roman law with (continental) Europe as a relatively homogeneous legal area, Paul Koschaker, committed in his monograph Europa und das römische Recht, published in 1947, the error of taking a part for the whole. In fact, Western legal tradition was based, in its entirety, not on Roman, but rather on canon law; embracing the common law of England, it represented – to cite Harold Joseph Berman – the first great “transnational legal culture”. At the end, some structural features of canon law are discussed, such as the frequent use of soft-law instruments and the respect for tradition, clearly visible in the approach to the problem of codification.

The Entrepreneur’s Prayer and the Scholastic Inspirations of Free-Market Economics

“…Late scholastics in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, Spanish theologians and canon lawyers (Brundage 2008;Giaro 2021) who referred to the work of Saint Thomas Aquinas and interpreted it concerning the conditions of their time, not only resulted in the renewal of Thomistic thought but also cognitively opened it to new areas. The need to reconsider the arguments used in various disputes -also related to issues now incorporated into economic sciences -was reinforced by the pressure from anti-scholastic Protestant thinkers but also practical problems resulting from the colonization of the New World, leading to various legal disputes.…”

Dispositivity in Russian Business Law

“…10 See, for instance, Strogov (2022); Tumeneva (2019);and Razuvaev (2019) at 12-14. 11 For more on the subject see for instance Zimmerman (1996) at 576-582 andGiaro (2021). essence of European ius commune occurred without prejudice to the continuation of the use of (local) customs by judges at the royal courts, who had been educated in (universal) Roman law and canon law.…”

A Network Analysis of Judicial Cross-Citations in Europe

“…With respect to the variable concerning countries of the former Comecon, the lack of significant results may also have some plausibility. It has been argued that, in regard to legal reform and legal thought, “the neighbouring eastern peripheries never communicate horizontally with each other, but always vertically with the center, to which they constantly aspire” (Giaro 2011, 23). With few exceptions (notably, the specific relationship between the Czech Republic and Slovakia), this is indeed the case here as courts from former Comecon countries have a preference to cite, for instance, the German supreme court rather than the supreme courts of other former Comecon countries.…”