Medical Students’ Attitudes towards Overweight and Obesity

Abstract

ObjectiveStudies from the USA have identified medical students as a major source of stigmatizing attitudes towards overweight and obese individuals. As data from Europe is scarce, medical students’ attitudes were investigated at the University of Leipzig in Leipzig, Germany.DesignCross-sectional survey containing an experimental manipulation consisting of a pair of vignettes depicting an obese and a normal weight 42-year-old woman, respectively. Vignettes were followed by the Fat Phobia Scale (FPS), a semantic differential assessing weight related attitudes. In case of the overweight vignette a panel of questions on causal attribution for the overweight preceded administration of the FPS.Subjects671 medical students were enrolled at the University of Leipzig from May to June 2011.ResultsThe overweight vignette was rated significantly more negative than the normal weight vignette (mean FPS score 3.65±0.45 versus 2.54±0.38, p<0.001). A higher proportion of students had negative attitudes towards the overweight as compared to the normal weight individual (98.9% versus 53.7%, p<0.001). A “positive energy balance” was perceived as the most relevant cause for the overweight, followed by “negligent personality trait”, “societal and social environment” and “biomedical causes”. Attributing a “positive energy balance” or “negligent personality trait” as relevant cause for the overweight was positively associated with negative attitudes.ConclusionThe results of this study confirm and complement findings from other countries, mainly the USA, and indicate that weight bias in the health care setting may be a global issue. Stigmatizing attitudes towards overweight and obesity are prevalent among a sample of medical students at the University of Leipzig. Negative attitudes arise on the basis of holding the individual accountable for the excess weight. They call for bringing the topic of overweight and obesity more into the focus of the medical curriculum and for enhancing medical students’ awareness of the complex aetiology of this health condition.

Prejudice against obesity in university students studying in health‐related departments

“…In their study of health education students, Pantenburg et al. found that 98.9% of the students had a negative attitude toward obese people . Similarly, Stein et al.…”

Differential Effect of Patient Weight on Pain-Related Judgements About Male and Female Chronic Low Back Pain Patients

“…Most previous studies examining pain judgments have asked participants to make ratings of text vignettes, 6,9,10,11 still images of patients, 8 or videos of computer-simulated patients. 30,31,56 Likewise, studies examining weight bias have tended to use text vignettes, 53,60 figure drawings, 24,28,72 or still images. 29,50,62,73,75 In contrast, participants in the current study rated videos of actual patients completing a standardized and highly relevant functional task.…”

Health awareness in female doctors

“…11 Pantenburg B reported that 84% were of normal weight and 10% were either overweight or obese. 12 In present study, out of 100 female doctors, 52 (52%) female doctors were consuming pure vegetarian diet while 48 (48%) female doctors were consuming mixed (vegetarian and non-vegetarian) food. 32 (32%) female doctors were eating outside food >3 times a week while 68 (68%) female doctors were eating outside food <3 times in a week.…”