Medical student opinions on character development in medical education: a national survey

Abstract

BackgroundRecently United States (US) medical schools have implemented curricular reforms to address issues of character in medical education. Very few studies have examined students’ opinions about the importance of character development in medical school. This cross-sectional study assessed US medical students’ opinions regarding character-focused education and their experiences receiving character feedback from educators. We mailed a questionnaire to 960 third year medical students from 24 medical schools. Respondents received a second questionnaire during their fourth year. Students answered three items that assessed their opinions regarding character development in medical education. They also indicated the frequency of positive/negative feedback regarding their character traits. We also tested associations between these opinions and various demographic, religious and spiritual characteristics. We used the χ2 test to examine bivariate associations between each demographic/religious characteristic and students’ opinions on character development or feedback.ResultsExcluding 41 ineligible respondents, the adjusted response rate for the first questionnaire was 61 % (n = 564/919) and 84 % (n = 474/564) for the follow-up questionnaire. Twenty-eight percent of students agreed that one could be a good physician without being a good person; 39 % agreed that educators should focus on science instead of students’ characters; 72 % agreed that it was educators’ responsibility to train students to have good character; 1 % of students reported no positive feedback from faculty regarding character traits; 50 % reported no negative feedback.ConclusionsUS students in clinical clerkships receive predominately positive feedback from educators regarding character traits. A majority of medical students, regardless of demographic and religious characteristics, are receptive to the role of character development in medical education. This finding suggests that character-based approaches toward ethics and professionalism training may find renewed receptivity among medical students despite recent “professionalism movement” fatigue.

Virtue in Medical Practice: An Exploratory Study

“…Carey et al ( 2015 ) investigated US medical students’ opinions on the character education they receive and find that medical students are generally receptive to character education 5 . However, what should such character education look like?…”

“…While it is no doubt influential in theory, empirical study of virtue in medicine is in its infancy, with only a small body of empirical work in existence (e.g., Schulz et al 2013 ; Carey et al 2015 ). In fact, a recent review (Kotzee and Ignatowicz 2016 ), found that empirical study of medical ethical decision-making is still completely dominated by rule-based approaches.…”

An Opinion Survey on Medical Education Technologies Prevalent And Innovative

“…[13] Several other studies also reported the feedbacks of students on teaching methodology and some also suggested for small group teaching method as a better strategy for better quality teaching. [16][17][18][19][20] …”

Effective Factors of Professional Ethical Competency in Medical Students : A Qualitative Study

“…Evaluations recently concentrated on behaviors rather than attitudes as behavior and attitude may be irrelevant due to the context effect [29]. However, professional behavior is a complex issue demanding frequent measuring in various learning contexts through a combination of different methods and instrumentations [6].…”

“…Professional ethical competency is defined through two approaches including character-based approach and an approach concentrating on visible performance and professional behaviors [6]. The two are sometimes combined to provide a more comprehensive definition; in better words, professional ethical competency is indeed considered as a professional way of conducting oneself based upon values and commitment [7].…”