Medical Student Milestones in Emergency Medicine

Abstract

Objectives: Medical education is a continuum from medical school through residency to unsupervised clinical practice. There has been a movement toward competency-based medical education prompted by the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) using milestones to assess competence. While implementation of milestones for residents sets specific standards for transition to internship, there exists a need for the development of competency-based instruments to assess medical students as they progress toward internship. The objective of this study was to develop competencybased milestones for fourth-year medical students completing their emergency medicine (EM) clerkships (regardless of whether the students were planning on entering EM) using a rigorous method to attain validity evidence.Methods: A literature review was performed to develop a list of potential milestones. An expert panel, which included a medical student and 23 faculty members (four program directors, 16 clerkship directors, and five assistant deans) from 19 different institutions, came to consensus on these milestones through two rounds of a modified Delphi protocol. The Delphi technique builds content validity and is an accepted method to develop consensus by eliciting expert opinions through multiple rounds of questionnaires.Results: Of the initial 39 milestones, 12 were removed at the end of round 1 due to low agreement on importance of the milestone or because of redundancy with other milestones. An additional 12 milestones were revised to improve clarity or eliminate redundancy, and one was added based on expert panelists' suggestions. Of the 28 milestones moving to round 2, consensus with a high level of agreement was achieved for 24. These were mapped to the ACGME EM residency milestone competency domains, as well as the Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) core entrustable professional activities for entering residency to improve content validity.Conclusions: This study found consensus support by experts for a list of 24 milestones relevant to the assessment of fourth-year medical student performance by the completion of their EM clerkships. The findings are useful for development of a valid method for assessing medical student performance as students approach residency.ACADEMIC EMERGENCY MEDICINE 2014;21:905-911

Distribution of Honors Grades Across Fourth‐year Emergency Medicine Clerkships

“…Both medical schools and residency programs have recently begun to implement competency‐based grading systems that seek to identify discrete entrustable professional activities that can be easily evaluated . If EM clerkships were to rely on competency‐based assessment, some of the subjectivity that contributes to grade inflation may be eliminated and perhaps less variability would be present in clerkship grades.…”

Pupil Prose Appraisal: Four Practical Solutions to Medical Student Documentation and Feedback in the Emergency Department

“…The specific objectives for note writing should be particular, but allow for some interpretation . A reasonable checklist for the evaluation of notes may include assessment of:…”

“…The Reporter–Interpreter–Manager–Educator (RIME) model has been proposed as a tool to contextualize, teach, and evaluate EMR documentation and may assist preceptors in evaluating learners …”

Clinical Assessment of Medical Students in the Emergency Department, a National Consensus Conference

“…Simultaneously, the executive committee derived “building blocks” of assessment from foundational source materials. 1, 3–9 Each contained the following: name, background and definition, benefits/drawbacks/alternatives to use in the clinical setting, areas of overlap with other domains of assessment, examples of how an assessment of this domain would appear on an assessment form in three formats (narrative, dichotomous, and an anchored ratings scale), and references.…”