Medical feminism, working mothers, and the limits of home: finding a balance between self-care and other-care in cross-cultural debates about health and lifestyle, 1952–1956

Abstract

Post-war medical debates about the psychiatric consequences of married women’s economic behaviour witnessed far more divergence and collision between perspectives than has often been acknowledged. Practitioners who approached women primarily as facilitators of family health—as wives and mothers—were mistrustful of the competing demands presented by paid employment. They were faced by a growing spectrum of opinion, however, which represented women as atrophying in the confines of domestic life, and which positioned work as a therapeutic act. Advocates of work tapped into anxieties about family instability by emphasizing the dangers posed by frustrated housewives, shifting clinical faith away from full-time motherhood, but nevertheless allowing responsibilities towards husbands and children to continue to frame argument about women’s behaviour. Doctors, researchers and social critics, in this context, became preoccupied with questions of balance, mapping a path which sought to harmonize public and private fulfilment, identity and responsibility. This article traces this discursive shift through a series of conferences held by the Medical Women’s International Association during the early-to-mid 1950s, connecting debates in Britain with systems of broader intellectual exchange. It enriches and complicates historical knowledge of post-war relationships between medicine and feminism, at the same time as offering a conceptual and linguistic context for modern discussion about work-life balance and gender. This article is published as part of a collection entitled “On balance: lifestyle, mental health and wellbeing”.

2019 Wilkins–Bernal–Medawar lectureLife begins at 40: the demographic and cultural roots of the midlife crisis

“…The importance of maintaining a healthy work-life balance without compromising family stability structured recommendations for women's self-realization in later life, as well as dictating debates about paid employment for women. 99 According to the older Pitkin, wives and mothers whose children had left home and whose husbands were 'sunk deeply in the miry ruts of their own business offices' needed to identify educational and career opportunities that utilized their skills and experience in order to prevent boredom, unhappiness and periods of personal crisis. 100 By contrast, educated college women needed to temper their commitment to work with more opportunities for play.…”

Self-help, marriage guidance and the making of the midlife crisis

“…The importance of achieving or maintaining a balanced life clearly structured recommendations for women's self-fulfilment in later life, as well as dictating debates about paid employment for women. 73 According to the older Pitkin, wives and mothers whose children had left home and whose husbands were 'sunk deeply in the miry ruts of their own business offices' needed to identify educational and career opportunities that made use of their skills and experience in order to prevent boredom, unhappiness and periods of personal crisis. 74 By contrast, college women -those educated in 'spinster factories' -needed to temper their commitment to work with more opportunities for play.…”

Pilot fatigue and the regulation of airline schedules in post-war Britain

“…Reflecting contemporary discussions about work-life balance, and the importance of home life for men as well as women, the Bader Committee argued that the 'home environment' was essential for the emotional health of pilots and was particularly important to mitigate the effects of personal stress 'leading to fatigue' . 69 Time at home had, the Bader Committee held, both physical and emotional benefits. To this end, pilot fatigue was transformed in regulatory discourse.…”