Medical color displays and their color calibration: investigations of various calibration methods, tools, and potential improvement in color difference ΔE

Abstract

Our laboratory has investigated the efficacy of a suite of color calibration and monitor profiling packages which employ a variety of color measurement sensors. Each of the methods computes gamma correction tables for the red, green and blue color channels of a monitor that attempt to: a) match a desired luminance range and tone reproduction curve; and b) maintain a target neutral point across the range of grey values.All of the methods examined here produce International Color Consortium (ICC) profiles that describe the color rendering capabilities of the monitor after calibration. Color profiles incorporate a transfer matrix that establishes the relationship between RGB driving levels and the International Commission on Illumination (CIE) XYZ (tristimulus) values of the resulting on-screen color; the matrix is developed by displaying color patches of known RGB values on the monitor and measuring the tristimulus values with a sensor. The number and chromatic distribution of color patches varies across methods and is usually not under user control.In this work we examine the effect of employing differing calibration and profiling methods on rendition of color images. A series of color patches encoded in sRGB color space were presented on the monitor using color-management software that utilized the ICC profile produced by each method. The patches were displayed on the calibrated monitor and measured with a Minolta CS200 colorimeter. Differences in intended and achieved luminance and chromaticity were computed using the CIE DE2000 color-difference metric, in which a value of ΔE = 1 is generally considered to be approximately one just noticeable difference (JND) in color. We observed between one and 17 JND's for individual colors, depending on calibration method and target.As an extension of this fundamental work 1 , we further improved our calibration method by defining concrete calibration parameters for the display, using the NEC wide gamut puck, and making sure that those calibration parameters did conform, with the help of a state of the art Spectroradiometer, PR670. As a result of this addition of the PR670, and also an in-house developed method of profiling and characterization, it appears that there was much improvement in ∆E, the color difference.

New Insights into Wine Color Analysis: A Comparison of Analytical Methods to Sensory Perception for Red and White Varietal Wines

“…For illustration and printing technology, Δ E ab * = 2.3 was proposed as a color threshold to measure the performance of printers and monitors . In the field of medical displays used for diagnosis, Δ E 00 = 1 is used as a color threshold . In the field of viticulture and enology, an oft-cited study using Spanish red wines proposed a color threshold of Δ E ab * = 3 for wine .…”