Media Portrayals of Hashtag Activism: A Framing Analysis of Canada’s #Idlenomore Movement

Abstract

The confluence of activism and social media-legitimized by efforts such as the Arab Spring and Occupy Movementsrepresents a growing area of mainstream media focus. Using Canada's #IdleNoMore movement as a case, this study uses framing theory to better understand how traditional media are representing activism borne of social media such as Twitter, and how such activism can ultimately have an impact in political and public policy debates. A qualitative framing analysis is used to identify frames present in media reporting of #IdleNoMore during its first two months by two prominent Canadian publications. Emergent frames show that hashtag activism as a catalyst for a social movement was embraced as a theme by one of the publications, therefore helping to legitimize the role of social media tools such as Twitter. In other frames, both positive and negative depictions of the social movement helped to identify for mainstream audiences both historical grievances and future challenges and opportunities for Canada's First Nations communities.

Movement Mobilization in the Age of Hashtag Activism: Examining the Challenge of Noise, Hate, and Disengagement in the #MeToo Campaign

“…The potentially strong impact of hashtags, according to Bonilla and Rosa, has to do with their capacity to link large numbers of tweets on a given topic as part of an “intertextual chain.” Previous studies of hashtag activism have focused on a variety of topics relating to the mechanics and functions of the tags’ usage. Such scholarship has covered, for example, the narrative structure of hashtag campaigns (Yang, ), their agenda‐setting function in relation to mainstream media (Carter Olson, ; Moscato, ), their role as a tool for mobilizing minority groups (Raynauld, Richez & Boudreau Morris, ), and their importance for the creation of shared collective identities (Ray, Brown, Fraistat, & Summers, ). Research has also looked at the role of hashtags for information‐seeking and support during natural disasters and weather events (Bruns & Liang, ; Lachlan, Spence, Lin, Najarian, & Greco, ).…”

Crowdsourcing Change: An Analysis of Twitter Discourse on Food Waste and Reduction Strategies

“…This empowerment of individuals has led to the advent of online activism, or the use of social media and other Web platforms to promote social change via "fundraising, community building, lobbying and organizing" (Lee & Hsieh, 2013, p. 818). Sometimes dubbed "slacktivism" or "hashtag activism" by critics (Fatkin & Lansdown, 2015;Moscato, 2016), this form of citizen participation is able to "leverage audience interest to amplify messaging. Retweeting, for example, allows a movement's members not present at an event or rally to still participate in the distribution of information and thus the shaping of public opinion (Moscato, 2016, p. 5;Penney & Dadas, 2014).…”

Social Television, #Hashtag & Virtual Citizenship

“…Communication on Twitter potential leverage for wider distribution allows users to cluster, re-broadcast, modify, or reply to ongoing messages and conversations (Penny,J., & Dadas, C.,2014,p.74-90) through the Hashtag. Hashtag a short phrases that follow hash or pound sign (#) as it is a function that allows users to classify their tweets (Moscato, Derek. 2014).…”