To develop an inclusion method for hard-to-separate organic
molecules
with wide guest scopes, we examined the control of guest selectivity
via external factors such as solvents, temperature, and additives
for the competitive inclusion of monosubstituted phenol isomers with
crystals of p-tert-butylcalix[4]arene 1. Guest selectivity was thus switched between two isomers
in the inclusion of cresol, fluorophenol, and bromophenol and between
three isomers in the inclusion of chlorophenol. The mechanism of guest
selectivity in chlorophenol inclusion was mainly determined using
X-ray crystal structural analysis and a comparison of the thermal
stabilities and the formation rates of inclusion crystals with each
isomer. Under kinetic control, the inclusion from decane at a low
temperature selectively yielded type-A (host/guest = 1:1) inclusion
crystals of p-isomer (1·p-chlorophenol) in which the host and guest molecules exhibited
CH−π and OH–π interactions. In aqueous solutions
at high temperatures, where water molecules inhibited the inclusion
of m-isomer, thermally stable type-B (host/guest
= 2:1) crystals of o-isomer (1
2·o-chlorophenol), in which a guest molecule
was included in a capsule constructed by two host molecules, selectively
formed. Furthermore, the inclusion from decane in the presence of
methanol produced a co-inclusion crystal of type-C (host/guest/additive
= 2:1:1) in which a 1:1 complex of m-isomer and methanol,
connected via an intermolecular hydrogen bond, was selectively included
by the distorted capsule of two host molecules to form 1
2·m-chlorophenol·CH3OH.