The structurally homologous protein disulfide isomerases and thioredoxins exhibit a 10 5 variation of redox equilibria. It is demonstrated that the kinetic distinction among these protein family members lies primarily in the rate of breakdown of the mixed disulfide intermediate. The conserved buried acid group serves as a proton transfer catalyst for the buried active site cysteine in the formation and breakdown of the mixed disulfide. The reduction rate of Escherichia coli thioredoxin by dithiothreitol is directly proportional to the fraction of Asp-26 in the protonated form over the pH range of 6 -9. The kinetic role of Asp-26 is further probed via differential solvent kinetic isotope effect measurements versus a D26N variant. The differential solvent isotope effect of 0.6 is consistent with a direct proton donation to the thiolate leaving group (Cys-35) via an enforced general acid catalysis by trapping mechanism. Such a donation necessitates a structural rearrangement as these two buried side chains are separated by 6 Å in both the oxidized and reduced forms of the protein.Despite substantial sequence variability, the mammalian and bacterial protein disulfide isomerases, as well as the ubiquitous thioredoxins, appear to share a common structural motif (1) and are generally assumed to utilize a common enzymatic mechanism to achieve their accelerated reactivities in both dithiol oxidation and disulfide reduction (Fig. 1). Although the conformation of the active sites are markedly similar (2, 3), there is a 10 5 -fold variation in redox equilibria between Escherichia coli thioredoxin (EЈ 0 ϭ Ϫ260 mV (4)) and the E. coli protein disulfide isomerase protein DsbA (EЈ 0 ϭ Ϫ0.1 mV (5)). Within the thioredoxin/protein disulfide isomerase family the active site disulfide (-CXXC-) sequence spans the top of the first turn of an a-helix (the a 2 helix in E. coli thioredoxin) with the sulfur of the first cysteine exposed for reaction with exogenous thiols and disulfides while the second cysteine is buried within the protein interior. Much of the research into the mechanism has focused on the reactions of the solvent exposed thiol (Cys-32 in E. coli thioredoxin). Particularly noteworthy is the quantitative correlation between the redox potential and the pK of this solvent exposed thiol observed for a series of protein disulfide isomerase variants (6). This correlation is also proposed to extend to the E. coli thioredoxin (7).Since K eq equals (k 1 /k Ϫ1 )⅐(k 2 /k Ϫ2 ) for Fig. 1, the large differences in redox equilibria between the protein disulfide isomerases and the thioredoxins must be manifested in the individual rate constants. E. coli thioredoxin exhibits a k 1 reaction rate of 120 M Ϫ1 s Ϫ1 with oxidized glutathione under the conditions reported for human PDI 1 ␣ domain in Fig. 1 (8). Given the similarity in the rate constants observed for this step, the major difference in kinetics exhibited by these two enzymes does not lie primarily in the reaction of the protein thiol with the target disulfide substrate. Hence,...