Measuring Toxicity Toward Women in Game-Based Communities

Abstract

Prior research into gaming toxicity in game-specific Reddit communities nearly always considers toxicity in aggregate, and so provides very few clues for a valid coding scheme for isolating toxic language and triggers that specifically target women gamers. Existing research offers a starting place for devising valid methods for measuring and detecting toxic language and toxic triggers within specified data sets, but that research is less useful is its applicability to game-related forms of toxicity targeting women gamers. Where this research had originally hoped to develop an automated method for scoring, limitations with automated detection of toxicity discussed within the paper prompted a shift to what the authors identify as a key intermediate step—better accuracy in toxicity detection by automated means—that will contribute to future achievements in reducing toxicity toward women and other targeted groups in gaming communities. This paper is intended to aid projects that aim to incrementally improve our understanding of toxicity toward women in games and game communities and how to effectively measure it. The conclusion of this research ultimately hopes to contribute to providing information to inform policies that create a safer and more respectful gaming environment for all gamers.

Esports Athletes on a Team or Club Are More Physically Active and Less Sedentary Than Equally Experienced, Casual Video Gamers

“…In our sample, 40% of esports athletes on a team or club were women. Researchers have suggested that females might be hesitant to participate in esports because gaming is typically viewed as a male-dominated activity, the industry has marginalized females, and gaming culture has a history of sexism against females (Belskie et al, 2023;Cote et al, 2023). Considering the barriers, females may be even more inclined to include vigorous physical exercise in their esports training routine in an effort to prove themselves in what many perceive as a maledominated activity.…”

“You’re Too Pretty to Be a Challenge Runner”: Changing “Gamers” in an Age of Live Streaming

“…Gaming is structured as an "adolescent, white, male activity" in which "the experiences of women and people of color are often overlooked" (Gray, 2014, p. 75). In online spaces, abuse and harassment of nonmale, non-White gamers is frequent enough to be quantitatively measured (Belskie et al, 2023;Evans & Llano, 2023). The persistent stranglehold on video gaming exercised by this toxic geek masculinity (Salter & Blodgett, 2017) is due, in part, to a lack of player visibility.…”