Measuring the importance of attributes in logistics research

Abstract

PurposeTraditional methods of capturing and determining logistics attribute importance have serious research limitations. The purpose of this paper is to introduce maximum difference (MD) scaling as a new research methodology that will improve validity in measuring logistics attribute importance, overcoming many of the limitations associated with traditional methods. In addition, this new research method will allow logistics researchers to identify meaningful need‐based segments, an important goal of logistics research.Design/methodology/approachThis paper provides an overview of MD scaling along with important research advantages, limitations, and practical applications. Additionally, a detailed research process is put forth so that this technique can be implemented by logistics researchers. Finally, an application of this technique is presented to illustrate the research method.FindingsThe importance of truck driver satisfaction attributes was analyzed using bivariate correlation analysis as well as MD scaling analysis. The two sets of results are compared and contrasted. The resulting rank order of attributes is very different and MD scaling results are shown to possess important advantages. As a result of this analysis, MD scaling analysis allows for meaningful, need‐based segmentation analysis, resulting in two unique need‐based driver segments.Practical implicationsFrom a practitioner viewpoint, knowing which attributes are most important will help in investing scarce resources to improve decision making and raise a firm's ROI. Although a number of relevant applications exist, the most important may include examining: the importance of customer service attributes; the importance of logistics service quality attributes; and the importance of customer satisfaction attributes.Originality/valueMD scaling is a relatively new research technique, a technique that has yet to be utilized or even explored in existing logistics and supply chain literature. Yet, evidence is mounting in other fields that suggest this technique has many important and unique advantages. This paper is the first overview, discussion, and application of this technique for logistics and supply chain management and creates a strong foundation for implementing MD scaling in future logistics and supply chain management research.

Examining Carrier Selection with Situational Choice Models

“…Hierarchical Bayes within Sawtooth Software (7.0) was used to analyze the MD data. Best practice in choice modeling suggests that Hierarchical Bayes is the "gold standard" of excellence (Garver, Williams, and LeMay 2010 ). The results from the Hierarchical Bayes analysis were rescaled so that the preference scores assigned to each transit time and rate would sum to 100 points, with higher scores refl ecting greater preference for the transit time and rate.…”

Technical and Technological Innovations and Quality in Road transport of Goods - Selected Aspects

“…Research conducted among Czech customers showed that the most important factors in assessing the quality of services in road transport of cargo are: no damage in packaging, keeping delivery dates, no damage to transported goods, no accidents in transport processes (Koniecny, Stetinova, 2006). From the practice point of view, knowledge about quality attributes determines the direction of development and investments and determines the success rate of carriers decision making processes (Garver et al, 2010). The faster the operators' response to the specific customer requirements, the higher they will be assessed.…”

Selecting E-Mobility Transport Solutions for Mountain Rescue Operations

“…Although contextually different, the study served as methodological guidance for the BWS analysis as presented in this article. Additionally, we followed the BWS steps as proposed by [86]. Accordingly, the first step comprised the setting of the study context followed by the identification of attributes.…”