Measuring personal beliefs and perceived norms about intimate partner violence: Population-based survey experiment in rural Uganda

Abstract

BackgroundDemographic and Health Surveys (DHS) conducted throughout sub-Saharan Africa indicate there is widespread acceptance of intimate partner violence, contributing to an adverse health risk environment for women. While qualitative studies suggest important limitations in the accuracy of the DHS methods used to elicit attitudes toward intimate partner violence, to date there has been little experimental evidence from sub-Saharan Africa that can be brought to bear on this issue.Methods and findingsWe embedded a randomized survey experiment in a population-based survey of 1,334 adult men and women living in Nyakabare Parish, Mbarara, Uganda. The primary outcomes were participants’ personal beliefs about the acceptability of intimate partner violence and perceived norms about intimate partner violence in the community. To elicit participants’ personal beliefs and perceived norms, we asked about the acceptability of intimate partner violence in five different vignettes. Study participants were randomly assigned to one of three survey instruments, each of which contained varying levels of detail about the extent to which the wife depicted in the vignette intentionally or unintentionally violated gendered standards of behavior. For the questions about personal beliefs, the mean (standard deviation) number of items where intimate partner violence was endorsed as acceptable was 1.26 (1.58) among participants assigned to the DHS-style survey variant (which contained little contextual detail about the wife’s intentions), 2.74 (1.81) among participants assigned to the survey variant depicting the wife as intentionally violating gendered standards of behavior, and 0.77 (1.19) among participants assigned to the survey variant depicting the wife as unintentionally violating these standards. In a partial proportional odds regression model adjusting for sex and village of residence, with participants assigned to the DHS-style survey variant as the referent group, participants assigned the survey variant that depicted the wife as intentionally violating gendered standards of behavior were more likely to condone intimate partner violence in a greater number of vignettes (adjusted odds ratios [AORs] ranged from 3.87 to 5.74, with all p < 0.001), while participants assigned the survey variant that depicted the wife as unintentionally violating these standards were less likely to condone intimate partner violence (AORs ranged from 0.29 to 0.70, with p-values ranging from <0.001 to 0.07). The analysis of perceived norms displayed similar patterns, but the effects were slightly smaller in magnitude: participants assigned to the “intentional” survey variant were more likely to perceive intimate partner violence as normative (AORs ranged from 2.05 to 3.51, with all p < 0.001), while participants assigned to the “unintentional” survey variant were less likely to perceive intimate partner violence as normative (AORs ranged from 0.49 to 0.65, with p-values ranging from <0.001 to 0.14). The primary limitations of this study are that our...

Subjective Happiness, Health and Quality of Life and Their Sociocultural Correlates among Younger Population in Malawi

“…However, the two constructs have remained largely underappreciated in the low-middle-income settings. The relatively higher disease burden, shorter life expectancy, and lower living standards in developing countries can be interpreted in terms of sociocultural and environmental determinants, such as age structure, gender disparities, low literacy rates, living environment, occupation and economic freedom, and the values and norms that guide peoples' beliefs and behaviour (Agorastos et al 2014;Galavotti and Schnell 1994;Tsai et al 2017; Development Impact Guest Blogger 2016; Decker and Constantine 2011; Gooneratne and Vitiello 2014). For instance, individuals with a higher socioeconomic status are more likely to be able to afford better housing, lead a healthy lifestyle, and enjoy higher quality of health and life compared to those in the lower socioeconomic strata (Zarini et al 2014;Bishwajit et al 2017; Amo-Adjei and Kumi-Kyereme 2015).…”

Intimate partner violence and contraceptive use in developing countries: How does the relationship depend on context?

“…Our national-and individual-level controls for whether women view intimate partner violence as acceptable are subject to the same limitations. Research has found that contextual information significantly impacts how women answer these questions (Tsai et al 2017), as does survey design (Yount et al 2011). In particular, DHS questions have been found to underrepresent the proportions of people who condone IPV (Schuler, Lenzi, and Yount 2011).…”

You can’t burn the house down because of one bedbug: a qualitative study of changing gender norms in the prevention of violence against women and girls in an urban informal settlement in India

“…Violence was, however, acceptable in some situations – such as infidelity - which might be interpreted differently depending on the perspectives of perpetrator and survivor. Recent evidence suggests that this loophole might be wider if transgression is perceived to be intentional rather than unintentional 32 .…”

“…Responses to survey questions on gender norms – such as those used in Demographic and Health Surveys – may differ from responses to more contextualised questions based on illustrative vignettes 32 . Over three months in 2016, we held a series of focus group discussions and individual interviews.…”