Measuring experience of and satisfaction with newborn care: a scoping review of tools and measures

Abstract

BackgroundStandardised measures on experience of care are essential to understanding the care women and newborns receive and to designing appropriate interventions and responses. This review builds on ongoing work in the realm of maternity care and complements it by reviewing existing tools and measures to assess experience of and satisfaction with the care of the newborn.MethodsWe conducted a scoping review of published literature to identify measures and tools of experience (physiological or indirect) and satisfaction with newborn care. We systematically searched five bibliographic databases from 1 January 2010 through 1 December 2022 and contacted professional networks. Using a predefined evidence template, we extracted data on the studies and the tools’ characteristics. We mapped the tools and measures against the WHO quality of care frameworks to identify the most frequent measured domains of care and to highlight existing gaps.ResultWe identified 18 292 records of which 72 were eligible. An innovative finding of this review is the inclusion of newborn perspectives through behavioural responses, physiological signals, pain profiles as well as other non-verbal cues as markers of newborn experience. Domains related to parental participation and decision-making, ensuring continuity of care and receiving coordinated care, were the most measured across the included tools.ConclusionComprehensive and validated instruments measuring all aspects of care are needed. Developing a robust theoretical ground will be fundamental to the design and utilisation of standardised tools and measures.Protocol registration detailsThis review was registered and published on protocol.io (dx.doi.org/10.17504/protocols.io.bvk7n4zn).

Childbirth experiences and post-partum depression among mothers in selected hospitals in Kiambu, Kenya

“…Although the control Group has a slightly higher percentage of mothers exhibiting these difficulties, both groups show a notable frequency of individuals expressing these feelings on an occasional basis. In a study to measure experience and satisfaction with newborn care, it was established that there is no standard tool to do so [25] and therefore the mothers may have responded from their subjective understanding of baby care.…”

Cultural diversity in maternity care in improving the quality of care services: a systematic review

“…Maternal and child healthcare services are crucial indicators of public health [2]. The experience of giving birth directly influences decisions about future childbirth and the choice between vaginal delivery and cesarean section [3].…”

Measuring women’s experiences during antenatal care (ANC): scoping review of measurement tools

“…Experience of care in this context includes but is not limited to effective communication, respect and dignity, and access to the social and emotional support of her choice [ 1 , 5 ]. There has been substantial progress in developing tools and methods to measure this phenomenon [ 6 , 7 ]. A global scoping review by Larson and colleagues assessed tools measuring women’s experiences across the continuum of maternal and newborn care, from antenatal care (ANC) through postnatal care (PNC) [ 6 ].…”