Measuring ensemble interdependence in a string quartet through analysis of multidimensional performance data

Abstract

In a musical ensemble such as a string quartet, the musicians interact and influence each other's actions in several aspects of the performance simultaneously in order to achieve a common aesthetic goal. In this article, we present and evaluate a computational approach for measuring the degree to which these interactions exist in a given performance. We recorded a number of string quartet exercises under two experimental conditions (solo and ensemble), acquiring both audio and bowing motion data. Numerical features in the form of time series were extracted from the data as performance descriptors representative of four distinct dimensions of the performance: Intonation, Dynamics, Timbre, and Tempo. Four different interdependence estimation methods (two linear and two nonlinear) were applied to the extracted features in order to assess the overall level of interdependence between the four musicians. The obtained results suggest that it is possible to correctly discriminate between the two experimental conditions by quantifying interdependence between the musicians in each of the studied performance dimensions; the nonlinear methods appear to perform best for most of the numerical features tested. Moreover, by using the solo recordings as a reference to which the ensemble recordings are contrasted, it is feasible to compare the amount of interdependence that is established between the musicians in a given performance dimension across all exercises, and relate the results to the underlying goal of the exercise. We discuss our findings in the context of ensemble performance research, the current limitations of our approach, and the ways in which it can be expanded and consolidated.

Measuring social interaction in music ensembles

“…The authors suggested that the introduction of extreme unexpected dynamical changes in a well-rehearsed piece is a very unusual scenario for professional musicians, leading to a disruption of the normal sensorimotor communication patterns. Papiotis et al [65] analysed the audio and motion capture recordings (movement of the bow) of a quartet playing exercises under two experimental conditions: solo (i.e. each musician performs her part alone using a stripped-down version of the score) and ensemble.…”

Score-Informed Source Separation for Multichannel Orchestral Recordings

“…Musicians played in an anechoic chamber, and, in order to be synchronous with the rest of the instruments, they followed a video featuring a conductor and a pianist playing each of the four pieces. Note that the benefits of having isolated recordings comes at the expense of ignoring the interactions between musicians which commonly affect intonation and time-synchronization [37].…”

Body sway reflects leadership in joint music performance

“…However, this measure is not sensitive to the direction of information flow between agents and may result in type I errors if time series are autocorrelated (45). A few previous observational studies on music ensembles used Granger causality to analyze bow movements, timbre variations, and body sway of performers (39,46,47). However, because these studies did not manipulate leadership assignment or visual information, it remains unclear whether previous findings reflect a motor byproduct of executing music scores or are related to higher order aspects of joint action, such as leader-follower communication.…”