Measuring cognitive-motor integration to detect prolonged performance declines post-concussion

Abstract

ObjectiveThere is a higher risk of re-injury for athletes with concussion history when returning to play, despite being asymptomatic and cleared for activity. One possible explanation is that current return to play assessments test thinking and moving separately, but sport activities often require their concurrent processing (cognitive-motor integration, CMI). The aim of this research is to characterize CMI performance across a range of ages and skill levels following concussion. We hypothesize that there will be CMI impairment, even when cognition and motor action measured separately are deemed recovered, and that impairment level is affected by age and skill level.Methods133 participants with concussion history (mix of youth, adolescent, university, and elite athletes) and 130 no-concussion controls (age/sex/skill matched) performed two eye-hand coordination tasks. Participants displaced a cursor from a central to peripheral targets by either sliding their finger on a vertically-oriented touchscreen or with decoupled eye-hand coordination (targets/cursor viewed on vertical screen but finger slid on second horizontal touchscreen with 180° cursor feedback rotation).ResultsChildren, young adult, and elite athletes with concussion history all had CMI performance deficits in movement planning, timing and execution, despite being asymptomatic and returned to play. Younger and less skilled athletes were more impaired relative to older/elite performers.ConclusionsCognitive-motor integration tasks are successful in detecting performance post-concussion relative to established assessment tools that test these domains separately. We propose that testing CMI performance, a skill crucial in sport, is important to comprehensively assess function post-concussion and to prevent re-injury.Competing interestsNone.

Sport experience is correlated with complex motor skill recovery in youth following concussion

“…This idea is in line with findings of previous concussion history studies of youths, varsity athletes, and elite athletes. There was an inverse relationship between CMI deficits and skill level across these studies (Brown et al., 2015; Dalecki et al., 2016; Hurtubise, 2016; Sergio et al., 2017). All of these results strongly suggest an important role of visuomotor sport‐related experience in compensation for CMI deficits post‐concussion.…”

“…Previous studies showed that post‐concussive CMI deficits had an inverse relationship with age and skill level (Brown, Dalecki, Hughes, Macpherson, & Sergio, 2015; Dalecki et al., 2016; Hurtubise, 2016; Sergio et al., 2017). Thus, one might expect that more years of eye–limb coordination‐related sports experience could compensate for CMI skill impairment.…”

Motor Deficits in Youth with Concussion History: Issues with Task Novelty or Task Demand?

“…In the present study, we expand on these findings with details about the time course of EHD deficits in youth with concussion history to include task demand. Eye-hand decoupling is an important and common skill on the sport-field, in particular, in popular contact sports such as American football, lacrosse or hockey [23].…”