Means Testing and the Heterogeneity of Housing Assets: Funding Long-Term Care in Spain

Abstract

The access to publicly funded long-term care (LTC) in Spain has been traditionally rationed through the use of means tests based on individuals' current income and needs. However, individuals' wealth, primarily housing assets, is progressively taken into account. Parallel to this feature, the responsibilities for the organization of LTC services have been devolved to region-states -autonomous communities (ACs), giving rise to some regional heterogeneity, though limited evidence has been reported on the underlying determinants. This paper examines the current role of housing assets in determining public and private funding for long-term care in Spain. Secondly, we present a qualitative and quantitative examination of the regional heterogeneity in the provision and public funding criteria determining eligibility for public support for LTC. Finally, we report survey evidence on the individual's willingness to sell (WTS) their housing assets in order to either totally or partially finance the access to LTC. Our findings suggest that housing assets are the main source of wealth accumulation at old age. Yet there is significant regional heterogeneity in the access to LTC resulting from regional differences in the means testing criteria. Progressively, all ACs are considering housing assets in their means testing criteria. Interestingly, individuals' willingness to sell their housing assets declines with age and is more common among less skilled and widowed individuals.

Devolution, Diversity and Welfare Reform: Long‐term Care in the ‘Latin Rim’

“…However, proponents of devolution argue that as a governance model it can give rise to competition (or cooperation) among regional governments and spill‐over effects, especially when a neighbouring government's performance is taken as a yardstick to evaluate regional welfare policy (Salmon 1987). Devolution also responds best to local preferences when heterogeneity in regional preferences makes the ‘strategy of equality’ (or uniformity) socially undesirable (Costa‐Font et al . 2006).…”

Housing Wealth and Housing Decisions in Old Age: Sale and Reversion

“…However, although housing can act as a self-insurance mechanism in old age, liquidity problems arise when long-term care (LTC) has to be paid for out of individual wealth. Yet, in countries such as Spain where the family still plays a key role (unlike in other central and northern European countries where financial independence is a key value) housing wealth is the main asset protecting the family in those areas where social protection is not universal, such as LTC services (Costa-Font et al, 2006).…”

Long-term care protection for older persons: A review of coverage deficits in 46 countries

“…For large parts of the older population, a major part of accumulated wealth consists of owning the residence where they live. The obligation to spend down wealth to finance LTC services may or may not include housing, but housing wealth is increasingly being included (Costa-Font et al, 2006). For the United States, it was found that housing wealth of nursing home entrants fell steadily over a six-year period, resulting in a median housing wealth of zero within six years after the initial nursing home entry (Banerjee, 2012).…”