May I see your ID, please? An explorative study of the professional identity of undergraduate medical education leaders

Abstract

BackgroundThe mission of undergraduate medical education leaders is to strive towards the enhancement of quality of medical education and health care. The aim of this qualitative study is, with the help of critical perspectives, to contribute to the research area of undergraduate medical education leaders and their identity formation; how can the identity of undergraduate medical education leaders be defined and further explored from a power perspective?MethodsIn this explorative study, 14 educational leaders at a medical programme in Scandinavia were interviewed through semi-structured interviews. The data was analysed through Moustakas’ structured, phenomenological analysis approach and then pattern matched with Gee’s power-based identity model.ResultsEducational leaders identify themselves more as mediators than leaders and do not feel to any larger extent that their professional identity is authorised by the university. These factors potentially create difficulties when trying to communicate with medical teachers, often also with a weaker sense of professional identity, about medical education.ConclusionsThe perceptions of the professional identity of undergraduate medical education leaders provide us with important notions on the complexities on executing their important mission to develop medical education: their perceptions of ambiguity towards the process of trying to lead teachers toward educational development and a perceived lack of authorisation of their work from the university level. These are important flaws to observe and correct when improving the context in which undergraduate medical education leaders are trying to develop and improve undergraduate medical programmes. A practical outcome of the results of this study is the facilitation of design of faculty development programmes for educational leaders in undergraduate medial education.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12909-017-0860-0) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Making the leap to medical education: a qualitative study of medical educators' experiences

“…A number of recent studies report the perceptions of individual clinical teachers as they juggle their competing identities; however, proffered solutions (e.g. in terms of developing career opportunities, time for teaching and professional development schemes) are often at a programmatic or organisational level because it is at this level that the chief stressors appear to be felt . However, as Monrouxe argues, ‘…identities are not fixed cognitive schemas; rather, identities are what we do’, and hence it is important to understand what factors, at an individual level, facilitate or impede the ‘doing’ or performance of medical education .…”

“…in terms of developing career opportunities, time for teaching and professional development schemes) are often at a programmatic or organisational level because it is at this level that the chief stressors appear to be felt. 16,17 However, as Monrouxe argues, '. .…”

Exploring the experience of postgraduate students in their transition from a health science to an educational scholarship in an African university setting

“…Multiple tensions associated with both becoming and being a clinician-educator have been reported (Sethi et al 2017;Sundberg et al 2017;Kumar et al 2011). These include: the perceived need to juggle multiple roles and manage multiple intersecting identities within a broader community that does not necessarily value their educational expertise; education being seen as a vast speciality, making it difficult as a generalist to keep up to date in all areas; and difficulties experienced in executing their role to reform medical education.…”

The ‘Octopus’ Skills Model of a Medical Professional: A Focus Group Discussion

“…However, defining competencies is complicated, and requires the judgment of the appropriate practitioners 11 . In addition to that, a medical professional needs not only to be a physician, but also must be able to maintain his professional identity which encompasses behavioral, learning, research, organizational, teaching and emotional skills 13 . The University Of New Mexico School Of Medicine concluded 13 traits including honesty, responsibility, reliability, critique, maturity, integrity, communication skills, respect and a few others to be a part of the medical professional 14 .…”