Maximizing the Potential of Digital Games for Understanding Skill Acquisition

Abstract

Gaming is a domain of profound skill development. Players’ digital traces create data that track the development of skill from novice to expert levels. We argue that existing work, although promising, has yet to take advantage of the potential of game data for understanding skill acquisition, and that to realize this potential, future studies can use the fit of formal learning curves to individual data as a theoretical anchor. Learning-curve analysis allows learning rate, initial performance, and asymptotic performance to be separated out, and so can serve as a tool for reconciling the multiple factors that may affect learning. We review existing research on skill development using data from digital games, showing how such work can confirm, challenge, and extend existing claims about the psychology of expertise. Learning-curve analysis provides the foundation for direct experiments on the factors that affect skill development, which are necessary for a cross-domain cognitive theory of skill. We conclude by making recommendations for, and noting obstacles to, experimental studies of skill development in digital games.

The relationship between habits and motor skills in humans

“…Complex skills are considerably more challenging to study, both technically and conceptually. Across many domains, greater and greater volumes of data are becoming available, raising the possibility of strongly data-driven methods for studying real motor skills that are acquired and improved over longer time-periods [55][56][57][58][59][60]. However, it is not clear whether such big-data approaches will be able to provide more fundamental insights into why and how improvements in performance take place.…”

Robustness of performance during domain change in an esport: A study of within-expertise transfer

“…Our results confirm that such a unified framework is not yet available. However, recent advances in our ability to collect data on complex tasks through telemetry [31,[43][44][45] provides cognitive science with the opportunity to identify new phenomena to be explained. We hope this incentivizes comprehensive theoretical approaches with the capacity to make clear and nuanced predictions about the presence and magnitude of transfer costs.…”

A randomised proof‐of‐concept trial on the effectiveness of a game‐based training of phoneme‐grapheme correspondences in pre‐readers

“…These games commonly comprise multimodal features (e.g., sounds, animations, text) that stimulate young children's attention and enhance motivation (van de Ven et al, 2017). This might be especially necessary for children who are struggling to master basic academic skills, such as reading, and need to remain motivated to practice the compromised skill for a prolonged period (Froyen et al, 2009; Stafford & Vaci, 2022). In this context, games are the ideal combination of massive, targeted exposure while maintaining the child's motivation and engagement (Prensky, 2003).…”